PAL MCIT Exemption Rule: When Franchise Tax Options Defeat MCIT

Special franchise taxpayers may defeat MCIT when the law gives a lower-tax option and an in-lieu-of-all-other-taxes clause. The PAL MCIT Exemption Rule protects a taxpayer with a special legislative franchise from being forced into the minimum corporate income tax when its franchise gives it a narrower and more favorable tax choice. For companies operating under […]

Void Marriage Co-Ownership: Property Partition After Annulment

Property acquired during a void marriage may be partitioned as co-owned if titles show acquisition during the union and ownership is unrebutted. Void marriage co-ownership means that property acquired during a marriage later declared void may still be divided between the former spouses if the property was acquired during their union and the registered owner […]

When Prosecutors File in the Wrong Court, Accused Persons Can Demand Accountability

Libel cases must be filed in the RTC. Prosecutors may be disciplined for continuing a case in a court with no jurisdiction. Prosecutors cannot keep a criminal case alive in a court that plainly has no jurisdiction. When the law clearly assigns a crime to a particular court, an accused person may challenge the case […]

Court Personnel Can Be Disciplined for Threats and Improper Text Messages Even Without Proven Bribery

Court personnel may avoid bribery liability absent proof, but still face discipline for improper text messages, threats, and conduct undermining public trust. Public officers, especially court personnel, may still face administrative liability even when a bribery accusation is not proven. The key doctrine is evidentiary separation: a court employee cannot be punished for bribery on […]

Intervention Is Not a Second Chance: Why Shareholders Need Proper Authority Before Fighting Corporate Property Cases

Shareholders and intervenors cannot appeal corporate property disputes without party status or board authority; intervention falls when the main case is dismissed. Shareholders, heirs, and corporate insiders cannot revive a lost corporate property dispute by appealing in their own names when they were merely intervenors, were not parties to the surviving case, or were never […]

Free Patent Fraud Proof Rule: When Reversion Fails in Land Cases

Free patent titles may survive reversion unless the State proves actual fraud with clear evidence in Philippine land title disputes. The Free Patent Fraud Proof Rule protects titled landowners from losing property merely because the government later questions a land patent. In Philippine property disputes, a registered free patent may still be attacked by the […]

Buying Land Through an Agent? The Buyer Bears the Risk if the Seller Had No Clear Authority

The Supreme Court held that buyers dealing with agents must verify clear written authority to sell land, or risk losing the property. A buyer of real property cannot safely rely on a person’s general authority to represent a corporation when the transaction involves the sale of land. When an alleged agent sells corporate real estate […]

DARAB Jurisdiction Rule: CLOA Cancellation Belongs to DAR

CLOA cancellation belongs to DARAB only when a real agrarian dispute exists; otherwise, the DAR Secretary has jurisdiction over the case. The DARAB jurisdiction rule in CLOA cancellation cases is now clear: a dispute over a Certificate of Land Ownership Award does not automatically belong before the DARAB unless the complaint itself shows a true […]

Registration Decree Priority: Why Land Titles Beat Tax Receipts

Registered land title prevails over tax declarations; tax receipts alone cannot defeat a decree of registration in Philippine property disputes. Registration Decree Priority is the rule every property claimant must understand: tax declarations and realty tax receipts may support a claim, but they do not defeat a decree of registration and an original certificate of […]