Insurance Agents Who Report Themselves as Self-Employed Cannot Easily Reclaim Employee Status Later

Tax returns declaring self-employment helped defeat an insurance agent’s employee claim, reinforcing the control test and agency classification. Self-employed professionals who consistently report their income as business or professional earnings may find those tax declarations used against them when they later claim employee status. For insurance agents, titles such as unit manager, branch manager, or […]

Statutory Taxpayer Refund Rule: Who Can Claim Excise Tax Refunds

Only the statutory taxpayer may claim an excise tax refund; a purchaser who merely bears the indirect tax cost has no standing. The Statutory Taxpayer Refund Rule means that a business which merely shoulders an indirect tax as part of the purchase price cannot automatically recover that tax from the BIR. In Philippine tax litigation, […]

When a Judge Acts on the Wrong Case, Good Intentions Are Not Enough

Judges may not decide cases outside their sala, even for good reasons. The Court fined two RTC judges for taking over vacant MTCC cases. Judges cannot decide, dismiss, or otherwise act on cases that are not pending before their own sala, even when they believe they are protecting an accused person’s liberty. The Supreme Court […]

Judges Cannot Shortcut Due Process When Issuing TROs and Injunctions

Courts may issue emergency TROs, but they cannot skip raffle, summons, notice, and hearings. An expired 72-hour TRO cannot be extended. A party threatened with a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction is entitled to notice, raffle safeguards, summons, and a real hearing before the court may impose lasting injunctive relief. The ruling in Sps. […]

When Court Delay Comes From Bad Records, Judges and Clerks Can Be Personally Sanctioned

Court delay from poor records management can lead to sanctions against judges and clerks, even after retirement, when litigants suffer needless delay. Litigants have a right not only to a judge who decides cases, but to a court that keeps track of them. When case files are incomplete, hearing settings are missed, summonses are delayed, […]

When Damage Awards in Corporate Cases Cannot Be Collected While an Appeal Is Pending

Moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees in intra-corporate cases cannot be immediately executed while appeal remains pending. Parties who win moral damages, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees in an intra-corporate case cannot automatically collect those amounts while the losing party’s appeal is still pending. Even if intra-corporate decisions are generally immediately executory, the Supreme […]

Court Funds Must Be Deposited Within 24 Hours: Why Good Faith Does Not Excuse Mishandled Judiciary Collections

Court personnel who delay depositing fiduciary collections may be liable for gross neglect despite good faith or restitution, preserving strict court fund accountability. Court personnel who receive bail bonds, fiduciary deposits, and other court collections cannot treat those funds as temporary office cash. The Supreme Court made clear that delayed deposits, undocumented withdrawals, poor bookkeeping, […]

A Missing Board Resolution Should Not Automatically Kill a Company’s Labor Appeal

A corporate president may validly sign a company’s forum shopping certification without a board resolution, preventing technical dismissal of a labor appeal. A company facing a labor standards order does not necessarily lose its day in court simply because its petition was signed by the corporate president without an attached board resolution. When the signatory […]

PAN Due Process Rule: Void BIR Tax Assessments in the Philippines

BIR tax assessments are void when the taxpayer is not served a required PAN stating the facts and law behind the deficiency. The PAN Due Process Rule protects taxpayers from immediate tax collection when the Bureau of Internal Revenue fails to prove that it sent the required Preliminary Assessment Notice. For businesses facing deficiency VAT, […]

Dissenting Stockholders Cannot Force a Buyout Unless the Corporation Has Retained Earnings

Dissenting stockholders may demand fair value, but payment is enforceable only when the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings to protect creditors. A dissenting stockholder’s appraisal right is not an automatic right to immediate cash. Even after a valid objection to a corporate amendment and even after an appraisal committee fixes the fair value of the […]