When a Stock Broker Fails to Deliver Shares, Clients Can Demand Their Money Back

Brokerage clients may rescind and recover payment when stock certificates are not delivered; pledged assets cannot be sold before the debt is liquidated. A brokerage client who pays for shares but never receives the stock certificates is not trapped waiting indefinitely for delivery: the client may rescind the transaction and recover the purchase price with […]

PAL Franchise MCIT Exemption: Why Special Tax Charters Matter

Special tax franchises prevail over general MCIT rules unless Congress clearly amends them, barring PAL’s deficiency tax assessment. The PAL Franchise MCIT Exemption Rule protects a taxpayer covered by a special legislative franchise from being subjected to a later general tax unless Congress clearly and expressly says so. For companies with tax incentives, franchise rights, […]

Tax Sale Jurisdiction Doctrine: Court Affirms Mandatory Deposit Requirement

The Supreme Court affirms that complaints challenging a tax sale must comply with mandatory deposit requirements, or the court lacks jurisdiction to hear the case. Property owners challenging the validity of a real estate tax sale must now ensure full compliance with the mandatory deposit requirement before a Regional Trial Court can hear their case. […]

Torrens Cancellation Due Process: Why Ex Parte Attacks Fail

Torrens titles cannot be cancelled by ex parte petitions when registered owners are not impleaded; void orders create no property rights. The Quasi in Rem Torrens Cancellation Rule protects registered landowners from losing titled property through an ex parte petition that fails to notify and implead the very persons whose titles will be cancelled. For […]

When Corporate Property Is Misused, Minority Stockholders May Sue Where the Company Is Based

Minority stockholders may file derivative suits at the corporation’s principal office when insiders allegedly misuse corporate property and board action is futile. Minority stockholders are not powerless when controlling insiders allegedly mortgage, encumber, or allow the foreclosure of corporate property without authority. If the injury belongs to the corporation and the board is unwilling or […]

Flawed Prior Title Rule: When an Older Land Title Loses in Court

An older land title may fail if its patent is flawed or unsupported; reconveyance still requires clear and convincing ownership proof. The flawed prior title rule protects landowners from losing property simply because an opposing claimant presents an older certificate of title. In a Philippine property dispute, an earlier title may still fail if the […]

When Related Companies Share Loans, Courts May Treat Them as One Economic Reality

Corporate affiliates may be treated as one when shared control, records, and transactions show the corporate form is used to evade a valid loan obligation. Businesses that route money, collateral, and obligations through sister companies, officers, stockholders, and related persons cannot assume that corporate separateness will always protect them from liability. When the evidence shows […]

Alien Land Ownership Bar: Why Foreign Buyers Cannot Control Philippine Land

Foreigners cannot claim ownership, reimbursement, or control over Philippine land bought through a Filipino spouse or nominee. The Alien Land Ownership Bar means that a foreign spouse or investor cannot use marriage, funding, or indirect arrangements to acquire control over Philippine land. For property owners, lessees, and businesses dealing with real estate in the Philippines, […]

Filing a Redemption Case Is Not Enough to Keep a Foreclosed Property

A borrower cannot stop possession after foreclosure by filing judicial redemption alone; payment or consignation of the redemption price is required. A borrower who wants to recover foreclosed real property cannot preserve possession merely by filing a case for judicial redemption. The redemption action must be timely, brought in good faith, and supported by payment […]

Execution Sale Buyers Can Register Shares Even While Related Cases Are Still Pending

Shares sold at execution may be registered to the buyer because personal property has no redemption period, subject to separate liability proceedings. Buyers of shares of stock at an execution sale do not have to wait for a redemption period that does not exist. Because shares are personal property, ownership may pass to the auction […]