When Share Ownership Is Disputed, Corporate Books Cannot Be Used as a Litigation Shortcut

A registered stockholder’s inspection rights cannot be defeated by merely alleging disputed share ownership. The case remains intra-corporate until ownership is resolved. A corporation cannot avoid a registered stockholder’s demand to inspect corporate books simply by recasting the dispute as a private ownership fight over shares. Where the parties appear in corporate records as stockholders […]

Notarized Surety Agreements Are Hard to Escape: Why a Forgery Defense Needs More Than a Handwriting Report

A notarized surety agreement cannot be defeated by denial alone; forgery must be proven by clear, convincing evidence, not weak handwriting comparison. Business owners, corporate officers, and loan sureties cannot lightly escape a notarized surety agreement by merely denying their signature or presenting an inconclusive handwriting report. When a person signs as surety for a […]

Shareholder Lawsuits Over Unfinished Corporate Projects Must Go to the Right Commercial Court

Shareholder derivative suits over corporate projects must be filed in special commercial courts and must strictly plead exhaustion and other requisites. A shareholder who sues on behalf of a corporation cannot avoid the special rules for derivative suits by labeling the case as one for specific performance. When the complaint seeks to enforce a corporate […]

Stock Transfers Cannot Be Blocked by Refusing to Update the Corporate Books

Valid share transfers must be recorded in corporate books; surrender is needed before new certificates issue, not before registration. A buyer of shares who holds validly transferred stock certificates has a right to be recognized in the corporation’s stock and transfer book, and a corporate secretary cannot defeat that ownership by refusing to record the […]

Even a 0.001% Stockholder Can Inspect Corporate Books in the Philippines

Even a 0.001% stockholder may inspect corporate books; corporations must prove bad faith or improper purpose before refusing access. Minority stockholders in Philippine corporations have a powerful inspection right: even a shareholder with only 0.001% ownership may demand access to corporate books, records, and financial statements, and the corporation cannot refuse merely because the shareholding […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personal Guarantors of Company Debts Without Clear Proof of Bad Faith

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company debts absent clear proof of bad faith, gross negligence, or patently unlawful corporate acts. A corporate officer who signs a company transaction does not automatically become personally liable when the corporation later fails to perform. The doctrine is practical and protective: creditors may pursue the corporation that […]

When a Docket Fee Dispute Is Not Enough to Disbar a Lawyer

Docket-fee disputes do not automatically prove lawyer deceit. The Court dismissed a disbarment complaint for lack of clear proof of fraud or bad faith. A lawyer is not automatically guilty of deceit or professional misconduct merely because the opposing party believes the complaint was framed to reduce docket fees. In disciplinary cases, the charge must […]

Proxy Fights Over Corporate Director Elections Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Proxy disputes tied to director elections belong in regular courts, not the SEC, even when framed as proxy-solicitation violations. Stockholders challenging proxies used to elect corporate directors must bring the dispute before the regular courts, not the Securities and Exchange Commission. Even when the objection is framed as a violation of SEC proxy-solicitation rules, the […]

When a Foreign Supplier Can Sue in the Philippines Without a Local Business License

A foreign supplier with an independent Philippine distributor may sue locally despite no license, and a dealer that benefited from the contract may be estopped. Foreign companies that merely appoint an independent Philippine distributor do not automatically lose the right to sue in Philippine courts, even if they have no local business license. For local […]