Foreign Companies Doing Business Without a Philippine License Cannot Sue in Philippine Courts

Unlicensed foreign corporations doing continuous business in the Philippines may be barred from suing locally, even when dealing with only one Philippine company. Unlicensed foreign corporations that make the Philippines a continuing base for sales, manufacturing, distribution, warranty support, or management participation may lose the right to sue in Philippine courts. A foreign company cannot […]

When Government Payables Can Be Garnished: Creditors Cannot Hide Behind State Immunity in Commercial Transactions

The Court held that government commercial payables may be garnished when tied to proprietary transactions, but a prior assignment can defeat a creditorโ€™s claim. A creditor who attaches money owed by a government office cannot automatically be defeated by the defense of state immunity where the government office was acting in a business or proprietary […]

Foreign Companies Cannot Be Bound by Philippine Court Orders Through Shortcut Summons

Foreign companies with no Philippine presence cannot be bound by injunctions or damages through extraterritorial summons in personal actions, the Court held. Foreign corporations with no Philippine office, agent, property, or voluntary appearance cannot be forced to obey local injunctions or pay damages merely because a complaint was sent to them abroad. The doctrine is […]

When a Stock Sale Fight Belongs Before the SEC, Not the Trial Court

Share transfer and corporate control disputes belong before the SEC when they affect ownership, voting rights, directors, and corporate governance. Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary civil cases when the real fight is over who owns, votes, records, or controls shares in a corporation. The doctrine from the Abejo-Braga controversy is straightforward but […]

Businesses Wrongfully Hit by Attachment Can Claim Damages on the Bond Even After Appeal

A business wrongfully hit by preliminary attachment may still claim damages on the bond during appeal before judgment becomes final. A party whose property was wrongfully attached is not left without a remedy simply because the case has already moved on appeal. If the attachment is later declared illegal, damages against the attachment bond may […]

A Missed Court Notice Does Not Automatically Void Execution Pending Appeal

A defective three-day notice does not void execution pending appeal when the losing party later receives a real chance to oppose but fails to act. Parties who lose a money judgment cannot automatically undo execution pending appeal merely by pointing to a defect in the three-day notice of hearing, especially when they were later given […]

When a Landlord Padlocks a Business: Lessees May Sue for Damages and Injunction Beyond Ejectment

A tenant locked out of business premises may sue for damages and injunction when the landlord disrupts peaceful enjoyment, not merely possession. A business tenant locked out of its leased premises is not limited to an ejectment-style possession case. When the real injury is the disruption of peaceful enjoyment and the resulting business damage, the […]

A Prior Conviction Does Not Automatically Bar a State Witness in Estafa and Falsification Cases

Prior conviction does not automatically bar a co-accused from becoming a state witness in estafa and falsification cases; credibility remains for trial. An accused person may still be discharged as a state witness even if another party argues that the witness has a prior conviction involving moral turpitude, because the trial courtโ€™s decision to discharge […]

Unpaid Loans Are Not Automatically Estafa: When Debt Collection Must Stay Civil

The Court held that non-payment of a simple loan is not estafa because ownership of the money passes to the borrower; the remedy is civil collection. A borrower who fails or refuses to pay a simple loan does not automatically commit estafa, because ownership of the borrowed money passes to the borrower and the creditorโ€™s […]