A Defective Criminal Complaint Can Void a Conviction, Even After a Guilty Plea

A conviction may be void when the complaint fails to allege the essential elements of the crime, even after a guilty plea in a serious criminal case. A criminal conviction cannot stand when the complaint or information fails to allege the essential facts constituting the offense charged. Even a guilty plea, even a serious accusation […]

Police-Assisted Counsel Can Still Make a Confession Admissible When the Accused Knowingly Accepts the Lawyer

Police-assisted counsel does not automatically void a confession. The Court affirmed rape convictions after finding valid counsel, voluntary statements, conspiracy, and failed alibi. A custodial confession is not automatically thrown out just because the lawyer was called in by the police. What matters is whether the accused was informed of the right to counsel, understood […]

When Courts Will Not Undo a Religious Corporationโ€™s Expulsion of Members

Religious corporation expulsions are generally beyond civil court review when based on doctrine, but courts may intervene for fraud, bad faith, or civil rights. Members of a religious corporation cannot usually ask civil courts to reverse their expulsion merely because they disagree with church discipline, especially when the controversy turns on faith, doctrine, membership, and […]

VFA Treaty-Concurrence Rule: When Foreign Pacts Bind the Philippines

Foreign military agreements bind the Philippines when Senate concurrence and treaty recognition requirements are met; policy objections alone fail. The VFA Treaty-Concurrence Rule confirms that a foreign military agreement may bind the Philippines when the Senate gives the constitutionally required concurrence and the other contracting State recognizes the agreement as a treaty. For citizens, advocacy […]

Domicile Requirement Doctrine: When Votes Cannot Cure Ineligibility

Election residence means domicile: short stays and voter transfer cannot cure ineligibility, and votes for a disqualified winner do not go to the runner-up. The domicile requirement doctrine warns candidates and voters that physical presence in a locality is not enough to qualify for elective office. A person who rents a house, appears in the […]

Ill-Gotten Wealth Disclosure: SC Opens PCGG Deals to Public

Citizens may demand disclosure of finalized PCGG-Marcos settlement terms; invalid compromises cannot waive taxes, criminal cases, or public claims. The Ill-Gotten Wealth Disclosure Doctrine gives citizens a powerful rule: when government negotiates the recovery of assets allegedly stolen from the public, the people may demand access to the completed terms, documents, and arrangements that affect […]

COMELEC Airtime Rule: When Broadcast Franchises Must Serve Elections

Broadcast franchises may carry election airtime duties; COMELEC Time is a valid public-service burden, not unconstitutional taking. Broadcast networks may be required to give free airtime for election purposes when that obligation is treated as a reasonable burden attached to their public franchise, not as an unconstitutional taking of private property. The COMELEC Airtime Rule […]

Anti-Competition Deregulation Doctrine: Why RA 8180 Fell

Deregulation is unconstitutional when tariff and inventory rules protect incumbents; the Supreme Court voided RA 8180 for blocking fair competition. The Anti-Competition Deregulation Doctrine warns that deregulation is unconstitutional when it opens a market in name but preserves barriers that protect dominant incumbents. For businesses, regulators, and investors, Tatad means that a law promoting free […]

VAT Constitutionality Rule: Why Tax Laws Survive Broad Attacks

Philippine VAT laws survive broad constitutional attacks unless taxpayers prove a concrete injury and a clear violation, not mere economic hardship. The VAT Constitutionality Rule tells taxpayers, publishers, real estate businesses, cooperatives, and other regulated industries that a tax law will not be struck down merely because it is unpopular, economically burdensome, or broadly alleged […]

When Government Wants Free Ad Space: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Rule on Taking Private Property for Elections

Government cannot compel newspapers to provide free election ad space without just compensation, even for voter education and public-interest purposes. Private publishers, media companies, and business owners cannot be forced to give the government free use of their property merely because the governmentโ€™s purpose is public, civic, or election-related. The Constitution allows the State to […]