When Tax Assessments Are Based on Guesswork, Taxpayers Can Fight Back

A tax assessment based on estimates and presumptions cannot stand without factual proof. Taxpayers may challenge speculative BIR computations before the CTA. Taxpayers may defeat a tax assessment when the government relies on presumptions, estimates, or mathematical projections instead of actual facts. In Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Island Garment Manufacturing Corporation, the Court reaffirmed […]

When a Contractor’s Worker Is Not Your Employee: The Supreme Court’s Payroll-and-Control Rule for Job Contracting Disputes

A contractor’s worker was not Petrophil’s employee because Gersher hired and paid him; transfer and demotion were upheld absent unfair labor practice. A company that receives services from a contractor is not automatically the worker’s employer simply because the work is performed inside its premises. Where the records show that the contractor hired the worker, […]

When Taxpayers Follow BIR Guidance, the BIR Cannot Later Punish Them Retroactively

Taxpayers who follow official BIR circulars in good faith cannot be penalized retroactively when the BIR later reverses its interpretation. Taxpayers who rely in good faith on an official BIR circular cannot later be made to pay deficiency taxes, surcharges, and interest merely because the government changes its mind. The ABS-CBN ruling is a powerful […]

Influence Fees Are Not Enforceable Business Expenses: When Commissions for Government Favor Become Void

A commission tied to political influence over government dollar allocations was void, warning businesses against treating influence fees as enforceable expenses. Businesses cannot enforce a commission agreement when the real bargain is payment for political influence over government action. Even if the payment is described as a sales commission, consultancy fee, facilitation fee, or business […]

Payroll Deductions Are Not Tax-Like Priority Claims: Why Credit Unions Cannot Jump the Line Without a Clear Law

A credit union’s payroll deduction right does not create first-priority credit status. Mandamus fails without a clear legal right to priority. Credit unions and cooperatives cannot treat authorized salary deductions as a superior, tax-like claim against an employee’s wages unless the law clearly gives them that priority. Even when an employer is required to deduct […]

A Payroll Settlement Is Not a Waiver of Disability Compensation

A labor settlement for wage-related claims does not automatically waive a separate disability compensation claim when illness supervenes during employment. Employers cannot treat a labor settlement for unpaid wages, salary increases, bonuses, or living allowances as an automatic release of a separate disability compensation claim. When an employee’s illness supervenes during employment, the compensability presumption […]

When Employers Stay Silent, Workers’ Compensation Defenses Can Be Lost

A delayed employer controversion waived defenses to a worker’s disability claim, where illness during employment triggered a presumption of compensability. A worker who develops an illness while performing dusty, cold, or physically taxing work does not have to prove his case like an ordinary civil lawsuit before compensation may be granted. Under the old Workmen’s […]

A Union Can Leave Its Federation Without Losing Its Legal Personality

A registered local union keeps its legal personality after disaffiliation, and a later CBA cannot defeat a pending certification election. A local union does not lose its legal personality merely because it disaffiliates from its mother federation or changes its name. For employers and competing unions, the practical consequence is direct: a pending representation dispute […]