Corporate Fiduciary Breaches Are Not Automatically Crimes

The Supreme Court held that director disloyalty under Sections 31 and 34 creates civil liability, not automatic criminal liability under Section 144. Corporate directors and officers may face serious civil liability for disloyalty, bad faith, or corporate opportunity violations, but they cannot be criminally prosecuted unless Congress clearly made the act a crime. The ruling […]

When a Corporation Keeps Money Without Board Approval, It May Still Have to Return It

A corporation lacking board consent may avoid contract liability, but it cannot keep money received without legal basis; refund, interest, and damages may follow. A company cannot avoid refund liability by saying it never approved a transaction, while also keeping money paid because of that same transaction. When corporate consent is absent, the supposed contract […]

PAGCOR Tax Exemption Rule: VAT Exempt, But Withholding Still Applies

PAGCOR remains VAT-exempt under its charter, but must still comply with withholding tax duties when benefits or payments are taxable. The PAGCOR Tax Exemption Rule protects a statutory franchise holder from VAT when its special charter was not expressly repealed, but it does not erase separate withholding duties imposed on the employer or withholding agent. […]

Non-Stock Associations Cannot Expel Members or Transfer Community Property Without Due Process and Corporate Purpose

The Supreme Court voided improper association expulsions and land transfers, protecting members’ due process, inspection rights, and corporate property. Members of a non-stock association are not powerless when officers remove them without notice or transfer association property to insiders. The Supreme Court confirmed that membership cannot be terminated by shortcut, and corporate property cannot be […]

Stockholders Can Inspect Corporate Records—Confidentiality Alone Is Not Enough to Stop Them

Corporations generally cannot stop stockholder inspection through pre-emptive injunction; confidentiality objections must be proven as defenses. Corporations cannot use a pre-emptive injunction to put stockholders on the defensive when they ask to inspect corporate records. The default rule is access: a stockholder who makes a written demand to examine corporate books, records of business transactions, […]

Corporate Mergers Do Not Automatically Trigger Separation Pay for Employees

A merger does not automatically dismiss employees or trigger separation pay when operations continue and contracts do not expressly provide merger benefits. Employees do not become automatically dismissed, and therefore do not automatically earn separation pay, merely because a corporate merger changes the legal structure above their employer. The controlling doctrine is simple but important […]

Corporate Dissolution Does Not End a Stockholder’s Right to Inspect Company Records

Corporate officers may still be liable for denying effective stockholder inspection of records during liquidation, even without clear malicious intent. Corporate officers cannot escape liability for denying a stockholder access to corporate books merely because the company has ceased operations or entered its winding-up period. A dissolved corporation remains alive for limited legal purposes, including […]

RMO No. 51-2016: ACIR Marissa O. Cabreros Designated as BIR Official Spokesperson to Streamline Public Communications

RMO No. 51-2016 designates ACIR Marissa O. Cabreros as the BIR’s official Spokesperson, centralizing all public communications to ensure clarity and consistency in tax matters. Businesses and taxpayers must now coordinate any media inquiries regarding the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) through a single, official spokesperson to ensure clarity and consistency in information dissemination. Effective […]

PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption: Casino Gaming Income Needs Only 5%

PAGCOR licensees owe only 5% franchise tax on casino gaming income; BIR cannot impose corporate income tax by circular. PAGCOR contractees and licensees operating authorized casinos are not automatically liable for corporate income tax on gaming income merely because the BIR issued a circular saying so. Under the PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption doctrine, income derived […]

When a Share Redemption Is Not a Taxable Dividend

Share redemption premiums are not automatically dividends. The Court allowed Goodyear’s refund and held no 15% FWT applied without unrestricted retained earnings. Companies that redeem shares from a foreign shareholder do not automatically owe dividend withholding tax merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. The controlling question is whether the payment is truly a […]