When Public Funds Claims Fail Without Evidence: Coco Levy Shares and the Burden of Proof

The Court held that alleged public funds must be traced with competent proof before shares can be forfeited as ill-gotten wealth. Government claims over alleged ill-gotten assets can fail even where the controversy involves public funds, political influence, and massive corporate shareholdings, if the State cannot prove the essential link between the disputed property and […]

Tax Exemption Split Rule: PAGCOR Pays Income Tax, Not VAT

PAGCOR must pay corporate income tax after R.A. 9337, but the BIR cannot impose VAT by regulation where the statute preserves exemption. The Tax Exemption Split Rule means that a franchise holder may lose one tax exemption without automatically losing all others. For Philippine businesses dealing with government franchises, gaming operations, or tax-exempt entities, the […]

RMC No. 35-2011: 10% Improperly Accumulated Earnings Tax on Closely Held Domestic Corporations

RMC No. 35-2011 clarifies the 10% IAET computation for closely held domestic corporations and limits allowable retained earnings to par-value paid-up capital. Closely held domestic corporations that keep earnings beyond the reasonable needs of the business must be ready to justify their retained earnings because the improperly accumulated taxable income is subject to a 10% […]

RMC No. 25-2011: Donor’s Tax Exposure on Below-Market Sale of Unlisted Shares and CAR Applications

RMC No. 25-2011 revokes a BIR ruling and confirms donor’s tax exposure when unlisted shares are sold below fair market value in CAR applications. Companies selling shares not traded through a local stock exchange must reassess Certificate Authorizing Registration applications where the declared consideration is lower than the fair market value of the shares. RMC […]

RMC No. 05-2011: Required Authority Documents for BIR Tax Credit Certificate Transactions

RMC No. 05-2011 requires corporations and individuals to prove authority before BIR TCC issuance, utilization, revalidation, or transfer. Tax Credit Certificate owners and their representatives must be ready to present clear proof of authority before transacting with the Bureau of Internal Revenue on TCC issuance, utilization, revalidation, or transfer. For corporations, the required proof is […]

VAT Refund Proof Rule: Why Missing Returns Can Defeat Tax Claims

VAT refund claimants must prove input VAT, zero-rated attribution, and non-application; missing VAT returns can defeat recovery. Businesses claiming VAT refunds must prove not only that input VAT was paid, but also that the same input VAT was never used against output tax liabilities. The VAT Refund Proof Rule means that a taxpayer seeking a […]

Statutory Taxpayer Refund Rule: Who Can Claim Excise Tax Refunds

Only the statutory taxpayer may claim an excise tax refund; a purchaser who merely bears the indirect tax cost has no standing. The Statutory Taxpayer Refund Rule means that a business which merely shoulders an indirect tax as part of the purchase price cannot automatically recover that tax from the BIR. In Philippine tax litigation, […]

When a Tax-Exempt Body Is Neither Private Nor Government-Owned

The Court upheld the PNRC Charter, recognizing the Red Cross as sui generis and preserving its statutory status and tax-related privileges. Organizations created for public-interest functions do not automatically fall into the usual boxes of private corporation, government agency, or government-owned and controlled corporation. For tax advisers, corporate counsel, donors, and regulated entities, the practical […]

Irrevocable Carry-Over Rule: Tax Refund Lost After Credit Election

Corporate taxpayers that elect carry-over of excess income tax under Section 76 lose the right to later demand a refund for the same credits. Corporate taxpayers that choose to carry over excess income tax payments cannot later convert the same amount into a refund claim. Under the Irrevocable Carry-Over Rule, the election made in the […]