Can You Refuse to Pay a Foreign Supplier Because It Has No Philippine License?

A Philippine company that contracts with a foreign supplier may be estopped from denying its capacity to sue, especially after merger liability is assumed. A Philippine company that contracts with a foreign software supplier may be barred from later arguing that the supplier cannot sue in Philippine courts simply because it has no Philippine license. […]

Corporate Veil Piercing Cannot Be Used to Seize a Non-Party Company’s Property

A creditor cannot seize a non-party corporation’s assets by piercing the corporate veil through post-judgment motion; jurisdiction and trial are required. A judgment creditor cannot use execution proceedings as a shortcut to seize the property of a separate corporation that was never sued, never served summons, and never tried as a party. The corporate veil […]

Carry-Over Irrevocability: When Tax Refunds Are No Longer Available

Choosing tax credit carry-over under Section 76 bars a later cash refund claim for the same excess income tax credits in the Philippines. Corporate taxpayers that choose to carry over excess income tax credits cannot later convert that choice into a cash refund claim for the same taxable period. The Carry-Over Irrevocability Doctrine makes the […]

Refund Doubt Rule: When Tax Errors Defeat a Refund Claim

Tax refunds fail when the same return shows a larger underpayment; the CTA may examine the full return before granting recovery. The Refund Doubt Rule means a taxpayer cannot recover an allegedly overpaid tax when the same return shows a larger underpayment for the same taxable year. For businesses seeking tax refunds in the Philippines, […]

Retirement Funds Are Not Company Assets Banks Can Seize for Corporate Debt

Employee retirement funds cannot be used to pay company bank debts until all plan liabilities to workers are satisfied, even after business closure. Employee retirement and provident funds cannot be treated as spare corporate assets available to satisfy an employer’s bank loans. When a company sets up a benefit plan for its workers, the fund […]

Withholding Agent Refund Rule: Smart’s Tax Credit Win

Withholding agents may claim refunds for overpaid foreign taxes, but treaty business profits without a PE are not Philippine-taxable royalties. The withholding agent refund rule gives Philippine companies a direct remedy when they over-withhold tax on payments to foreign suppliers: the company that withheld and remitted the tax may pursue the refund, even if it […]

Minority Stockholders Can Inspect Corporate Records Unless the Corporation Proves Bad Faith

Minority stockholders may inspect corporate books unless the corporation proves bad faith, improper use, or illegitimate purpose. Minority stockholders do not have to prove their good faith before they can inspect corporate books; the corporation that refuses inspection must prove improper motive, bad faith, or illegitimate purpose. That rule matters in tax, corporate governance, and […]

Withholding Agents Can Claim Tax Refunds for Foreign Suppliers — But Must Return the Money to the Real Taxpayer

Withholding agents may claim refunds for wrongly withheld taxes, but must return recovery to the foreign taxpayer; software payments may be business profits, not royalties. A Philippine withholding agent that mistakenly remits final withholding tax on payments to a foreign company may pursue the refund itself, even if it is not related to that foreign […]

When a Merger Brings Workers Into a Unionized Company, the CBA May Follow Them

Absorbed employees in a merger may be covered by the surviving company’s union shop clause, affecting CBA compliance and workforce integration. Companies that acquire or absorb another business through merger cannot treat incoming employees as a separate class outside the surviving company’s existing collective bargaining agreement. When absorbed workers become regular employees of a unionized […]

Tax Carry-Over Irrevocability: Why Refund Claims Can Be Lost

Corporate taxpayers that choose carry-over for excess income tax credits cannot later claim a refund for the same amount under Section 76. The Tax Carry-Over Irrevocability Doctrine means that a corporation that chooses to carry over excess income tax credits cannot later convert that same carried-over amount into a cash refund or tax credit certificate […]