When a Vice President Is Ousted, the Case May Belong to the SEC — Not the Labor Arbiter

Corporate officers elected under by-laws may need to challenge removal as an intra-corporate dispute, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporation’s by-laws may not always have an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals. Where the dispute is inseparably tied to the election, appointment, […]

When Corporate Officers Are Not Personally Liable for Company Debts

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company debts absent bad faith, unlawful acts, express solidary undertaking, or a specific law imposing liability. Corporate officers are not automatically personally liable for the debts of the companies they represent. For business owners, creditors, suppliers, and tax professionals, the rule is practical and important: a signature, negotiation, […]

GOCC Employees May Unionize Under the Labor Code When the Corporation Has No Original Charter

GOCC employees may pursue Labor Code union rights when their employer has no original charter, even if government-owned or controlled. Employees of a government-owned corporation are not automatically civil service employees. When the corporation was organized under the general corporation law and has no original charter, its employees remain governed by the Labor Code and […]

Tax Refund Offset Doctrine: Why Deficiency Assessments Matter

Tax refunds may be denied or remanded when a deficiency assessment questions the same return supporting the taxpayer’s refund claim. The Tax Refund Offset Doctrine means a taxpayer cannot secure a tax refund while an unresolved deficiency assessment for the same taxable year casts doubt on the return supporting that refund. For businesses, especially banks […]

Foreign Branches Are Taxed Only on Profits Actually Remitted Abroad

Foreign branches are taxed only on profits actually remitted abroad; the Supreme Court allowed a refund where the BIR included the tax itself in the base. Foreign corporations with Philippine branches may contest a branch profit remittance tax assessment when the Bureau of Internal Revenue computes the 15% tax on an inflated base that includes […]

When a Tax Refund Claim Meets a Deficiency Assessment, the CTA Must Decide Both Together

A taxpayer’s refund claim must be resolved together with any related deficiency assessment to determine the true tax due or refundable amount. A taxpayer claiming an income tax refund cannot rely on an overpayment return alone when the government has raised a deficiency assessment for the same taxable year. The refund case must determine the […]

When Corporate Papers Are Not Proof of Payment: Why Share Buyers Need Receipts and Stock Book Records

Corporate papers and officer titles do not prove share payment or ownership without competent evidence and stock book recording. A person who buys shares in a corporation cannot rely on board resolutions, secretary’s certificates, or an officer title alone to prove payment or ownership. The controlling lesson is practical and unforgiving: when money changes hands […]

Family Corporations Cannot Use Informal Governance to Escape a Valid Property Sale

Close family corporations may be bound by informal property sales when directors knew of the act and failed to promptly object in writing. Close family corporations cannot casually treat corporate formalities as optional when convenient, then invoke those same formalities to undo a completed sale. When a corporation is effectively run by a dominant family […]

A Corporation’s Lawsuit Belongs Where Its Principal Office Is — Not Where Its Branch or Letterhead Appears

A corporation’s residence for venue is its principal office in its articles, not branch or letterhead addresses, allowing the Cebu collection case to proceed. Corporations suing to collect money, enforce contracts, or recover business assets cannot choose venue based on convenience, branch offices, or addresses appearing in commercial documents; for venue purposes, a corporation resides […]