When the BIR Keeps an Overpayment, It Cannot Charge Interest on the Same Money

A taxpayer overpayment already held by the government must reduce later deficiency interest; the BIR cannot charge interest on funds it should credit or refund. Taxpayers who overpay taxes by mistake are not automatically delinquent on the full amount of a later deficiency if the government was already holding money that rightfully belonged to them. […]

When Corporate Debts Stay Corporate: The Clear Evidence Rule for Piercing the Veil

Corporate officers and stockholders are not personally liable for company debts absent clear proof of fraud, guarantee, or misuse of corporate personality. Corporate officers, stockholders, and directors are not personally liable for a company’s debt merely because they participated in board action, later sold their shares, or were connected with the transaction. A claimant who […]

A Dissolved Corporation Can Still Be Sued When Its Liabilities Survive

A dissolved corporation may still face suit and judgment enforcement for liabilities that arose before dissolution, especially when another entity assumed those obligations. Corporate dissolution is not a magic shield against lawsuits, judgments, or collection efforts. When a corporation’s cause of action or liability arose before dissolution, and especially when another entity assumed its obligations, […]

When a Company Buys Back a Shareholder’s Shares, the Dispute May Belong Before the SEC, Not the Regular Courts

Share buyout disputes tied to corporate shares may be intra-corporate controversies, not ordinary collection cases, requiring specialized corporate jurisdiction. A shareholder who is promised payment for the surrender or buyback of corporate shares may not always sue in the ordinary courts for collection. When the dispute arises from a stockholder’s agreement with the corporation involving […]

Imported Finished Goods Can Turn Royalty Deductions Into Tax Assessments

Royalty payments to foreign affiliates may be disallowed as deductions when computed on imported finished goods outside the governing regulatory approval. Philippine companies cannot automatically deduct royalty payments to foreign affiliates merely because the payments are described as business expenses. When a royalty or technical service fee is computed on finished goods imported from the […]

Private Corporations Cannot Buy Public Land: Why a Government Award Is Not a Vested Right Until the Law Is Fully Followed

Private corporations cannot claim vested rights over defective public land awards and may lease, not purchase, alienable public land. Private corporations that win a government award over public land do not automatically acquire ownership rights if the sale process was legally defective or if the Constitution bars corporate ownership. In Tagum Doctors Enterprises v. Apsay, […]

Corporate Asset Transfers Do Not Fail Just Because Formalities Were Attacked Years Later

Delayed attacks on corporate asset transfers may fail where shareholders knew, acquiesced, and waited too long to object to a reorganization. Corporate reorganizations are not automatically defeated by delayed attacks on shareholder consent, late by-laws, or technical objections raised only after the business has already moved on. For owners, creditors, and tax planners, the lesson […]

When Occasional Port Calls Still Trigger Philippine Income Tax for Foreign Shipping Companies

Foreign corporations with only occasional Philippine port calls may still owe tax on Philippine-source freight income, computed on gross receipts. A foreign company does not escape Philippine income tax merely because it has no branch, office, or license to do business in the country. If it earns income from Philippine sources, even through isolated port […]

Foreign Dividend Tax Refunds Require Proof of Actual Tax-Sparing Benefit

Philippine dividend tax refunds based on tax-sparing credits require proof that the foreign parent actually qualified for the foreign tax credit. Philippine subsidiaries claiming a refund or tax credit on dividends paid to a foreign parent must prove more than the existence of a treaty-like or statutory tax-sparing clause. They must show that the foreign […]