When Mandamus Fails: Why Companies Cannot Use Receivership to Undo Foreclosure Without a Clear Legal Right

Companies cannot use mandamus or receivership to recover foreclosed assets without a clear legal right, proper venue, and existing property interest. A distressed company cannot use mandamus and receivership as shortcuts to recover control of foreclosed assets unless it first shows a clear, enforceable legal right, the correct venue, and an existing property interest that […]

Removed Corporate Trustees May Still Recover Damages Even When Reinstatement Becomes Moot

An unlawfully ousted trustee may still recover damages even when reinstatement becomes moot because the office term has expired. A corporate officer or trustee who was unlawfully ousted is not automatically left without a remedy merely because the term of office has already expired. When reinstatement is no longer possible because the office term has […]

Foreign Brand Owners Can Sue Counterfeiters in Philippine Courts Even Before Doing Business Locally

Foreign trademark owners may sue in Philippine courts to stop counterfeiting despite no local business operations or pending trademark office cases. Foreign companies that own internationally protected trademarks may go to Philippine courts to stop local counterfeiting and unfair competition, even if they are not doing business in the Philippines and even if related trademark […]

When Government Buys a Private Corporation, Its Officers May Face Anti-Graft Jurisdiction

Government-acquired corporations may fall under anti-graft jurisdiction when public funds and government functions transform their accountability status. Corporate officers and employees cannot avoid anti-graft investigation merely because their company began as a private corporation. When the government acquires a corporation to perform government-related functions, that corporation may become government-owned or controlled for purposes of public […]

When Congress Changes a Tax Franchise, Tax Exemptions Can Disappear Overnight

Franchise tax exemptions may be withdrawn by Congress, but penalties may be removed when the taxpayer’s liability was genuinely uncertain and controversial. A company operating under a legislative franchise cannot assume that an old in-lieu-of-all-taxes clause will permanently shield it from income tax. When Congress validly amends the tax law and withdraws prior franchise exemptions, […]

Taxpayers Cannot Save a Failed Assessment Case by Raising Exemption Too Late

A taxpayer cannot raise a tax-exemption theory for the first time in court; officer bonuses tied to a land sale were disallowed, and surcharge plus interest were sustained. A taxpayer who accepts the tax character of a transaction during the administrative assessment stage cannot later ask the courts to treat the same income as tax-exempt […]

Tax Refund Claims Fail When Exemptions Are Stretched Beyond the Statute

Tax refunds and exemptions must be clearly authorized by statute; related business operations and late filings can defeat otherwise valid claims. Taxpayers claiming refunds must prove that their case falls clearly within the exact words of the tax exemption or refund statute; courts will not enlarge a partial tax refund by implication, business necessity, or […]