When Sequestered Shares Are Converted, Tax and Asset Recovery Strategy Belongs to the Executive Unless Grave Abuse Is Shown

The Court held that converting sequestered SMC shares into preferred shares was a preservation measure, not a government asset sale or COA-covered disposition. Sequestered corporate shares may be restructured to preserve value without being treated as a taxable or audit-governed sale of government property, so long as ownership has not yet been finally adjudicated and […]

Corporate Appeals Should Not Die on Missing Paperwork Alone

The Supreme Court held that a corporate petition should not be dismissed solely for a missing authority document when substantial compliance is later shown. A corporate appeal should not be defeated merely because the petition initially lacked a secretaryโ€™s certificate or board resolution, when the officer who signed was in a position to verify the […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Turn Boardroom Dismissals Into NLRC Cases

Corporate officers who are also directors or stockholders must bring dismissal and compensation disputes before regular courts, not the NLRC. Corporate officers who are also directors or stockholders cannot automatically bring dismissal, reinstatement, backwage, commission, or compensation claims before the NLRC. When the dispute concerns the removal or rights of an elected corporate officer, the […]

Payroll Treatment Can Help Prove Employee Status in Executive Termination Disputes

Payroll records, BIR forms, benefits, and leave credits helped prove that a high-ranking administrator was an employee entitled to pursue labor claims. A company that treats a manager as an employee for years through payroll, benefits, statutory contributions, withholding taxes, leave credits, and performance appraisals may be barred from later claiming that the same person […]

When a Former Company Lawyer May Still Represent the Other Side

A former company lawyer was not disciplined because no confidential corporate secret or prohibited conflict was proven in the later adverse representation. A former corporate lawyer does not automatically commit a conflict of interest merely because he later appears for someone sued by his former client. The decisive question is narrower: did the lawyer use […]

When a Stock Broker Fails to Deliver Shares, Clients Can Demand Their Money Back

Brokerage clients may rescind and recover payment when stock certificates are not delivered; pledged assets cannot be sold before the debt is liquidated. A brokerage client who pays for shares but never receives the stock certificates is not trapped waiting indefinitely for delivery: the client may rescind the transaction and recover the purchase price with […]

When Corporate Property Is Misused, Minority Stockholders May Sue Where the Company Is Based

Minority stockholders may file derivative suits at the corporationโ€™s principal office when insiders allegedly misuse corporate property and board action is futile. Minority stockholders are not powerless when controlling insiders allegedly mortgage, encumber, or allow the foreclosure of corporate property without authority. If the injury belongs to the corporation and the board is unwilling or […]

Bank Disputes Belong First With the BSP, Not the Regular Courts

Bank stockholders cannot bypass the BSP by filing an RTC case for receivership when the dispute involves unsafe banking practices and bank regulation. Bank stockholders cannot use an ordinary intra-corporate case to ask a trial court to place a bank under receivership or management control when the dispute is really about unsafe banking practices, insider […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Proceed Even Without a Formal BIR Assessment

Fraudulent tax return cases may proceed without a formal BIR assessment; a DOJ referral is not an appealable tax assessment before the CTA. Taxpayers suspected of filing fraudulent tax returns cannot stop a tax evasion case simply by arguing that the Bureau of Internal Revenue has not yet issued a formal assessment. When the alleged […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Liable for Employee Money Claims

Corporate officers are not automatically liable for employee money claims without summons, due process, and proof of bad faith or statutory grounds. Company presidents, directors, and managers cannot be made personally liable for labor money claims merely because the corporation closed, failed to pay employees, or may no longer have assets to satisfy a judgment. […]