Invalid BIR Assessments: When Failure to Serve a PAN and Late Collection Defeat a Tax Case

A tax assessment was voided after the BIR failed to prove PAN service, improperly served the FAN, and began collection after prescription had expired. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax or percentage tax assessments may challenge the assessment and collection itself when the Bureau of Internal Revenue fails to prove actual service of the Preliminary Assessment […]

BIR Assessments Are Void When Replacement Revenue Officers Audit Without a New LOA

BIR assessments may be void when replacement revenue officers continue an audit without a new LOA, even if a memorandum of assignment was issued. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax, withholding tax, VAT, and compromise penalty assessments should closely verify whether the revenue officers who actually conducted the audit were named in a valid Letter of […]

CWT Refunds Can Fail Without Detailed Tracing to Gross Income in the Annual ITR

A CWT refund claim was denied despite BIR Form 2307 support because the taxpayer failed to trace withheld income to gross income in its annual return and ledger. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit of excess creditable withholding taxes cannot rely on BIR Form 2307 certificates, SAWT schedules, or broad revenue totals alone; they […]

Late or Defective Tax Protests Can Make BIR Assessments Final and Unappealable

A taxpayer lost the chance to contest a Php9.9M BIR assessment after failing to prove timely appeal and valid administrative protest. Taxpayers who receive a BIR deficiency tax assessment must act quickly and prove every jurisdictional date, because a late, unsupported, or defective administrative protest can cause the assessment to become final, executory, and demandable […]

CWT Refund Denied When Taxpayer Cannot Trace Withheld Income to ITR Sales

CWT refund claim denied because the taxpayer failed to trace withheld income payments to revenue declared in its income tax return despite BIR Form 2307 evidence. Corporate taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit certificate for excess creditable withholding tax must do more than present BIR Form 2307 certificates and show that reported sales exceed […]

Taxpayers Can Lose Warrant Challenges by Filing Petitions Through Licensed Courier

A taxpayer’s warrant challenge was dismissed after a petition sent by licensed courier was received late, leaving the VAT assessment issues unresolved. Taxpayers challenging a warrant of distraint and/or levy or a warrant of garnishment must treat the 30-day Court of Tax Appeals filing period as jurisdictional and must file the petition using an allowed […]

Casino Tax Refunds: Gaming CWT Can Be Recovered, But Non-Gaming Credits Need Full Tracing

Casino licensee won a partial CWT refund for exempt gaming revenues, but lost its non-gaming CWT claim for failure to trace income to its tax return. Casino operators and PAGCOR licensees seeking refunds of creditable withholding taxes must prove two different things: that gaming revenues are covered by the PAGCOR tax exemption, and that non-gaming […]

VAT Refund Claim Upheld After Commissioner Repeats Previously Rejected Objections

CTA denied the Commissioner’s reconsideration bid and sustained a partial VAT refund for excess input VAT from zero-rated sales after repeated objections failed. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds should treat the trial-level record as decisive: once the Court of Tax Appeals has evaluated the documents and granted a partial refund, a motion for reconsideration that merely […]

Late-Served BIR Assessment Notices Can Void VAT and EWT Assessments

A late-served BIR assessment notice with an expired payment deadline can violate due process and void VAT and EWT assessments despite valid waivers. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should check not only the amount assessed, but also the date the assessment was actually served and whether the BIR meaningfully addressed their protest arguments. A formal […]

Tax Refund for Bahay Bonds Interest Upheld as Asset-Backed Securities Were Not Deposit Substitutes

CTA affirmed a P1.656M refund for final withholding tax on Bahay Bonds 2, holding the asset-backed securities were not deposit substitutes. Special purpose entities that issue asset-backed securities under an approved securitization plan may have a strong refund position when final withholding tax is imposed on interest income as though the securities were deposit substitutes. […]