VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost When BIR Refusal Is Treated as an Immediate Denial

VAT refund appeal dismissed after BIR refusal to receive the claim was treated as immediate denial, making the taxpayerโ€™s CTA filing late. VAT-registered taxpayers pursuing input VAT refunds must treat a BIR refusal to receive a complete administrative claim as a potentially appealable denial, not as a reason to wait for the 90-day action period […]

Importation Records Alone Cannot Sustain Deficiency Income Tax and VAT Assessments

Importation records alone did not justify deficiency income tax and VAT assessments, and the Commissionerโ€™s rehashed motion for reconsideration was denied. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax and VAT assessments based mainly on alleged undeclared importations have a strong procedural and evidentiary defense: importation, standing alone, does not automatically prove undeclared sales, VATable receipts, or taxable […]

Petroleum Sellers May Recover Excise Tax on LPG Sold to Tax-Exempt Buyers

Petroleum sellers may recover excise tax on LPG sold to tax-exempt entities if they prove the exempt sale and payment of the tax. Petroleum manufacturers and importers that paid excise tax on products later sold to tax-exempt entities may still pursue a refund or tax credit, because the exemption can attach to the petroleum product […]

Taxpayers Can End Assessment Litigation Through a Court-Approved Compromise Settlement

A taxpayer ended a disputed BIR assessment through a court-approved compromise after proving payment, doubtful validity, and NEB approval. Businesses facing disputed BIR assessments should treat compromise settlement as a serious litigation option when the assessment is arguably doubtful in validity, but they must be ready to prove that the compromise was properly authorized, paid, […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Make Tax Refund and Tax Credit Victories Final

A late government appeal made a CTA refund or tax credit victory final, with service on the OSG controlling the appeal deadline. Taxpayers who win a refund or tax credit case before a CTA Division may be able to rely on that victory becoming final when the Commissioner fails to perfect an appeal on time, […]

Late Certiorari Filings Can Sink Challenges to BIR Garnishment Orders

Taxpayers challenging BIR garnishment must file on time, attach certified copies, and comply with CTA e-filing rules or risk dismissal. Taxpayers challenging BIR collection actions must move quickly, attach the proper certified documents, and comply with electronic filing requirements, because even serious objections to an assessment may be dismissed outright when a petition for certiorari […]

Late Tax Appeals Can Defeat Even Substantive BIR Assessment Challenges

A taxpayerโ€™s late appeal from a BIR assessment decision was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, confirming the strict 30-day Court of Tax Appeals deadline. Taxpayers who receive an adverse assessment decision from the Commissioner must file their appeal with the Court of Tax Appeals within the 30-day statutory period, because even potentially serious objections to […]

Late Appeals From BIR Assessment Decisions Can Lose Before the Merits Are Heard

Taxpayers must prove the FDDA receipt date; unsupported claims and delivery estimates cannot save a late appeal from dismissal for lack of jurisdiction. Taxpayers contesting a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must be prepared to prove when they actually received it, because an unsupported receipt date can cause the entire tax assessment appeal to be […]

Customs Forfeiture Appeals Can End Once the Commissioner Orders Release of the Seized Vessel

A customs forfeiture appeal was closed after the Commissioner reversed the forfeiture and ordered release of the tugboat, making the dispute moot. Importers, vessel operators, and customs stakeholders facing seizure or forfeiture proceedings should reassess their litigation strategy when the Bureau of Customs itself reverses the forfeiture and orders the property released, because the Court […]

BIR Withdrawal of Warrant Ends VAT Assessment Case After Due Process Challenge

A VAT assessment case ended after the BIR withdrew a collection warrant, agreed to proper service, and allowed the taxpayer to protest administratively. Taxpayers facing collection through a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy should not assume that immediate judicial litigation is the only path forward. Where the assessment documents were allegedly not properly served and […]