Excise Tax Refund Granted for Distilled Spirits After Premature RA 11467 Implementation

Distilled spirits taxpayer wins PHP66.37M refund after court finds RA 11467 excise tax hike unenforceable before printed Official Gazette publication. Alcohol manufacturers and other excise taxpayers may challenge tax collections based on a law that was enforced before its valid effectivity date, especially where the Bureau of Internal Revenue relied only on online publication or […]

Rice Importers Need Valid Import Permits Before Arrival or Risk Seizure and Forfeiture

Rice shipments without required import permits may be seized and forfeited, even if duties were paid and eligibility documents exist. Rice importers cannot rely on a certificate of eligibility, advance payment of duties and taxes, or a later release permit to cure the absence of the required import permit when the shipment arrives. For importers, […]

Casino VAT Refund Claims Require the Right Legal Basis, Not Just Proof of Input Tax Payment

Gaming operators cannot refund all input VAT by proof of payment alone; exempt sales are not zero-rated, but statutory taxpayer VAT may be recoverable. Gaming operators and other VAT-exempt businesses cannot treat every input VAT payment as automatically refundable merely because VAT was passed on by suppliers. The more important question is whether the taxpayer […]

Unauthorized BIR Audit Voids Deficiency Income Tax and VAT Assessments

A tax assessment was voided because the BIR audit continued without a valid Letter of Authority, defeating deficiency income tax and VAT collection. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax and VAT assessments should closely examine whether the revenue officers who audited them were covered by a valid Letter of Authority, because an assessment issued from an […]

Condominium VAT Refunds Still Require Proof of Actual Erroneous Payment

Condominium dues are not VATable, but the taxpayer lost its refund claim for failing to prove actual erroneous payment and valid input VAT credits. Condominium corporations seeking VAT refunds cannot rely on the settled rule that association dues are not subject to VAT unless they can also prove the exact amount actually and erroneously paid […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Cancelled When BIR Revenue Officers Lack Proper Authority

The CTA cancelled a P119.3M BIR assessment after finding that reassigned revenue officers lacked a valid Letter of Authority to conduct the audit. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely examine whether the revenue officers who actually conducted the audit were properly authorized by a valid Letter of Authority, because an assessment issued from an […]

Late Tax Credit Appeals Remain Jurisdictionally Fatal Despite TRAIN Law Changes

Late tax credit petitions remain jurisdictionally barred when filed beyond the old 120+30-day rule, and TRAIN Law changes will not automatically apply retroactively. Taxpayers pursuing refund or tax credit claims cannot assume that later, more favorable procedural amendments will save a judicial appeal filed beyond the old 120+30-day period. Where the claim arose before the […]

Deficiency VAT Assessment Canceled After BIR Ignored Taxpayer’s Protest Arguments

A deficiency VAT and EWT assessment was canceled after the BIR failed to address the taxpayer’s PAN reply and served the final demand after the payment due date. Taxpayers who receive a Preliminary Assessment Notice should not treat their reply as a mere formality: when the BIR proceeds to issue a final assessment without meaningfully […]

Customs Seizure Appeals Can Be Dismissed When Importers Miss Pre-Trial Requirements

A customs seizure appeal was dismissed after the petitioner failed to file a pre-trial brief and repeatedly missed pre-trial despite notice. Importers and claimants challenging customs seizure or forfeiture actions must treat pre-trial compliance as a decisive litigation requirement, because a petition may be dismissed without any ruling on the merits if the petitioner fails […]

Taxpayers Can End BIR VAT Assessment Cases Through Court-Approved Compromise Settlements

A disputed VAT assessment was settled after the BIR accepted a 40% compromise on doubtful validity and the Court approved the agreement as final judgment. Taxpayers facing disputed BIR assessments may be able to end litigation through a properly approved compromise settlement, but only if the offer is paid, authorized, documented, and approved by the […]