A Company That Took Over a Business Cannot Automatically Take Over Its Lawsuit

A business takeover does not automatically transfer lawsuit rights. Only the real party in interest may appeal or recover civil liability in court. A corporation that informally takes over another company’s business does not automatically acquire the right to pursue that company’s court case. For business owners, creditors, and accused persons facing civil liability in […]

When Prosecutors File in the Wrong Court, Accused Persons Can Demand Accountability

Libel cases must be filed in the RTC. Prosecutors may be disciplined for continuing a case in a court with no jurisdiction. Prosecutors cannot keep a criminal case alive in a court that plainly has no jurisdiction. When the law clearly assigns a crime to a particular court, an accused person may challenge the case […]

When a Lawyer Takes Money for Fake Court Connections, Disbarment Can Follow

A lawyer was disbarred for taking client money under the pretense of using court connections to secure a detainee’s release and for ignoring disciplinary proceedings. Clients who are asked to pay a lawyer for supposed court influence or special connections should treat the demand as a serious ethical red flag: a lawyer may be disbarred, […]

Municipal Trial Courts Cannot Stop an Accused from Leaving the Philippines

Only Regional Trial Courts may issue hold-departure orders in covered criminal cases; lower courts cannot casually restrict an accused person’s right to travel. Only Regional Trial Courts may issue hold-departure orders in criminal cases, and only in cases within their exclusive jurisdiction. For accused persons, witnesses, employers, and litigants, the ruling draws a practical constitutional […]

When the Court Uses the Wrong Procedure: Why Summary Cases Must Stay Summary

A judge may be disciplined for using ordinary procedure in summary criminal cases, but unjust judgment liability still requires proof of bad faith or deliberate wrongdoing. Litigants in minor criminal cases have a right to the simplified procedure that the law requires, and a judge who ignores that procedure may be disciplined even when no […]

Search Warrants for Tax Violations Require More Than Unpaid Purchase Prices

Judges must find probable cause for the specific tax offense charged before issuing a search warrant; non-payment alone cannot justify seizure. Tax-related search warrants cannot rest on a bare allegation that someone failed to pay for imported goods, duties, or taxes; a judge must personally determine probable cause for the specific tax or customs offense […]

A Firearm Permit Issued by the Wrong Official Will Not Save an Illegal Possession Case

A defective firearm permit from an unauthorized official is not a defense to illegal possession; good faith cannot defeat malum prohibitum liability. A person charged with illegal possession of a firearm cannot rely on good faith, official rank, or a locally issued permit if the law requires a different approving authority. In People v. Neri, […]

Military Trial After Martial Law? The Supreme Court Says Civil Courts Take Over

Civilians cannot remain before a military tribunal after martial law when no valid arraignment gave it jurisdiction; prosecution must move to civil courts. When martial law ends, civilians cannot be kept indefinitely before military tribunals merely because a case began there. If the military body never validly acquired jurisdiction before its authority ended, the case […]

When a Judge Must Step Aside: Family Ties Can Destroy Confidence in a Criminal Case

A judge related to a party must inhibit before acting. Later withdrawal after arrest or failed settlement does not cure the due process problem. A party facing a criminal complaint may question a judge’s participation when the judge is related to one of the parties within the prohibited degree, because judicial neutrality is not only […]

Unpaid Loans Are Not Automatically Estafa: When Debt Collection Must Stay Civil

The Court held that non-payment of a simple loan is not estafa because ownership of the money passes to the borrower; the remedy is civil collection. A borrower who fails or refuses to pay a simple loan does not automatically commit estafa, because ownership of the borrowed money passes to the borrower and the creditor’s […]