When Aggravating Circumstances Fail, Death Penalty Must Fall: The Proof Rule in Murder Cases

Supreme Court reduced a murder death sentence to reclusion perpetua after ruling that most alleged aggravating circumstances were not proved. A person convicted of murder cannot receive the harshest possible penalty unless every alleged aggravating circumstance is proved with the same discipline required for the crime itself. In People v. Cortes, the Supreme Court held […]

Delayed Reporting Does Not Defeat a Child Rape Case When Fear and Dependence Explain the Silence

Delayed reporting and minor inconsistencies did not defeat a child rape conviction, but improper charging reduced the penalty to reclusion perpetua. A child rape complaint does not fail merely because the victim stayed silent, reported late, or remembered peripheral details imperfectly. When the testimony is candid, consistent on the material act, and supported by circumstances […]

Judges Are Protected for Good-Faith Errors, But Not for Basic Legal Ignorance

A judge is protected for good-faith judicial errors, but may be fined for gross ignorance when a basic rule on reckless imprudence is violated. Judges are not disciplined merely because they make wrong rulings, but they may be sanctioned when the mistake reveals ignorance of a basic legal rule that every trial judge is expected […]

Judges Who Abuse Case Parties Can Be Declared Unfit for Office Even After Dismissal

A judge may be held administratively liable for exploiting a litigant’s pending case through improper personal conduct, even if prior dismissal makes the penalty moot. Judicial office does not shield a judge from administrative accountability when the alleged misconduct occurs in a private setting but involves a party whose case is pending before him. A […]

Resident Alien Filing Rule: Tax Exemption Still Requires Filing

Resident aliens must file Philippine income tax returns even when claiming exemption; non-filing can still trigger criminal tax liability. The Resident Alien Filing Rule means that a person may be exempt from paying Philippine income tax and still be criminally liable for refusing to file an income tax return. For foreign nationals living in the […]

Arias Auditor Liability Rule: When Approval Is Not a Crime

A public officer’s approval or audit signature is not a crime unless evidence proves knowing participation, bad faith, or conspiracy. The Arias Auditor Liability Rule protects public officers from criminal conviction based solely on a signature, approval, or audit clearance, unless the evidence shows knowing participation, bad faith, or a duty to investigate the irregularity. […]

Taking Abaca From Another’s Land Can Be Theft Even When Ownership Is Disputed

Taking crops from land possessed and cultivated by another may be theft, even if title is disputed; tax declarations helped prove possession and ownership claim. People who enter land possessed and planted by another person cannot avoid theft liability merely by saying that the land is public, untitled, or subject to an ownership dispute. When […]

Self-Defense Fails Without Evidence: Why Flight and Treachery Can Seal a Criminal Conviction

Self-defense failed where the accused admitted hacking the victims but offered no corroborating proof; flight and treachery supported conviction. A person who admits inflicting the wounds but claims self-defense carries the burden of proving that defense with clear and convincing evidence. In People v. Maranan, the Supreme Court made clear that a bare story of […]