A Confession Alone Is Not Enough: How Corpus Delicti Protects the Accused in Criminal Trials

A confession alone cannot convict without independent proof that the crime occurred, but conspiracy can make a lookout liable for robbery with homicide. A criminal conviction cannot rest on a confession standing alone. Before an out-of-court admission may support guilt, prosecutors must first prove that a crime actually happened through evidence independent of the confession. […]

A Guilty Plea in a Capital Case Is Not Enough Without a Real Safeguard Against Mistake

A guilty plea in a capital case requires safeguards, but substantial compliance may sustain conviction while lack of required votes prevents death penalty. An accused who pleads guilty to a capital offense is not automatically beyond protection: the trial court must still make sure that the plea is informed, voluntary, and supported by a record […]

Holding the Victim Can Make You Liable as a Principal in Homicide

Holding a victim during a fatal attack can make a person liable as a principal in homicide when the act enables the killing and shows common criminal purpose. Someone who does not personally deliver the fatal blow may still be convicted as a principal in homicide when his act directly enables the killing. The key […]

Self-Defense Does Not Require Perfect Proportionality When the Threat Is Immediate

The Court acquitted an accused who used a gun against an armed attacker, holding that self-defense does not require exact weapon proportionality. A person who reacts to an imminent armed attack is not judged by the calm arithmetic of hindsight. In Lacson, the Court recognized a practical self-defense rule: when danger is sudden, real, and […]

Joining a Robbery Gang Can Make Every Member Liable for the Killing

Group robbery participants may be liable for robbery with homicide when conspiracy is proven, even if they did not personally inflict the fatal wound. A participant in a group robbery may be punished for the killing and injuries committed during the raid even if the prosecution cannot prove that he personally fired the fatal shot. […]

When a Confession Can Convict: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Rule on Voluntary Admissions and Re-Enactments

The Court held that a voluntary extrajudicial confession and re-enactment can sustain conviction despite later coercion claims and alibi. A criminal conviction may stand on an extrajudicial confession when the prosecution proves that the admission was made freely, voluntarily, and with sufficient safeguards against coercion. For accused persons, police investigators, and private complainants, the Caramonte […]

When Alibi Fails: Positive Identification Can Sustain a Robbery with Homicide Conviction

Positive eyewitness identification prevailed over alibi, sustaining a robbery with homicide conviction where the accused failed to prove physical impossibility. A criminal defendant cannot rely on alibi when credible eyewitnesses positively identify him at the scene of the crime and his own version of events still leaves him close enough to have committed the offense. […]

When a Group Attack Becomes Homicide, Not Murder: What Proof Is Needed to Convict as Principal or Accomplice

Group assault liability depends on proof of each accusedโ€™s acts. The Court reduced murder to homicide and treated non-stabbing participants as accomplices. A person who joins a violent attack is not automatically guilty as a principal in murder. Where conspiracy, treachery, evident premeditation, and a clear intent to kill are not proven, courts must classify […]

Bare Constitutional Attacks Will Not Overturn a Conviction When the Evidence Is Sufficient

A criminal appeal failed where constitutional objections were foreclosed by precedent and multiple witnesses supported the trial courtโ€™s factual findings. A criminal appeal cannot succeed on constitutional slogans alone when the prosecution has proved the required acts through competent witnesses and the accused has chosen not to present contrary evidence. In Alejandrino, the Supreme Court […]