Government Tax Case Dismissed Due to Prescription and Demurrer

CTA dismisses criminal tax case due to expired prescriptive period and demurrer to evidence, highlighting limits on government enforcement for unpaid income taxes. Taxpayers and business owners can take note that criminal cases for failure to pay assessed income taxes may be dismissed if the government does not timely file the Information within the prescriptive […]

Helping Call the Victims Can Make a Pimp Equally Liable for Qualified Trafficking

The Supreme Court affirmed that coordinated acts in offering victims for sex can prove conspiracy and qualified trafficking, even if money receipt is disputed. A person need not personally negotiate every detail, receive the money, or be the main operator to be convicted of qualified trafficking in persons. When the evidence shows that an accused […]

Drug Plea Bargaining Objections Must Be Raised Early or They Are Waived

Prosecutors who oppose RA 9165 plea bargains must raise all grounds early; objections based only on DOJ guidelines may be overruled. Prosecutors in drug cases cannot hold back objections to plea bargaining and later ask courts to reopen the case on grounds they never raised. When the prosecution opposes a plea bargain only because it […]

Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule: When BIR Tax Charges Fail

Criminal tax acquittals after demurrer are final unless grave abuse is shown, but civil tax liability may still proceed separately. The Tax Demurrer Acquittal Rule gives accused taxpayers and corporate officers powerful protection: once a criminal tax case is dismissed after the prosecutionโ€™s evidence fails, the acquittal is generally final, and the government cannot use […]

No-Receipt Illegal Recruitment: Testimony Can Convict

Illegal recruitment needs no receipt if credible testimony proves unauthorized overseas job promises; Dela Concepcion conviction and fines were affirmed. The no-receipt illegal recruitment doctrine makes clear that a recruiter cannot escape criminal liability simply because victims did not keep or produce written receipts. In overseas employment scams, credible testimony showing that an unlicensed person […]

Mangrove Conversion Rule: When Fishpond Work Becomes a Crime

Mangrove work that alters protected forest can be criminal conversion; tax declarations, inherited use, and good faith do not bar conviction. The Mangrove Conversion Rule means that a person may face imprisonment and fines not only for creating a new fishpond, but also for continuing to alter, improve, excavate, or use a mangrove forest in […]

Connections Fraud Rule: Fake BIR Contacts Can Mean Estafa

Estafa applies when fake BIR contacts induce tax payment; forged receipts may prove falsification through circumstantial evidence. Public officials and intermediaries who claim they can use government โ€œconnectionsโ€ to lower taxes or speed up title transfers may face serious criminal liability when money is taken and a fake receipt is issued. The Connections Fraud Rule […]

Unobjected Income Testimony Can Support a Multimillion-Peso Damages Award After Wrongful Death

Unobjected salary testimony may support loss of earning capacity in a criminal case, allowing heirs to recover civil damages despite missing payroll records. A family seeking civil damages after a killing is not automatically defeated by the absence of payroll records, income tax returns, or receipts. Where testimony on the deceased personโ€™s salary is admitted […]

A Lawyerโ€™s Criminal Conviction Can End the Right to Practice Law

A lawyer convicted of homicide may be disbarred when the facts show moral turpitude; commutation does not restore the privilege to practice law. A final conviction for a crime involving moral turpitude can cost a lawyer the privilege to practice law, even when the underlying offense is homicide and even when the lawyer later receives […]

Court Funds Are Public Trust Funds: Why Missing Bail and Filing Fees Can Lead to Dismissal and Criminal Charges

Court personnel who mishandle bail, legal fees, and fiduciary funds may face dismissal, forfeiture of benefits, disqualification, restitution, and criminal charges. Court employees who receive bail bonds, legal fees, and other judiciary collections cannot treat those funds as informal office cash, personal advances, or money to be deposited later. The Supreme Court made clear that […]