Income Tax Returns Can Help Prove Lost Earning Capacity in Criminal Cases

Income tax returns may prove lost earning capacity in death cases, helping heirs recover damages when income is properly documented. Families seeking damages after a wrongful death may recover more than burial expenses and moral damages when they can prove the victim’s earning capacity through competent evidence, including income tax returns. People v. Caratao is […]

When a Victim Has Intellectual Disability, Credible Testimony Can Still Prove Rape

The Supreme Court affirmed a rape conviction based on credible testimony from a victim with intellectual disability, rejecting alibi and modifying damages. A rape conviction may rest on the coherent testimony of a victim with intellectual disability when the trial court finds her competent to perceive, remember, and narrate what happened, and when her account […]

Delayed Reporting Does Not Defeat a Rape Case When Fear, Family Control, and Trauma Explain the Silence

Delayed reporting did not defeat a daughter’s rape testimony, but the Court acquitted on a second count lacking separate proof beyond reasonable doubt. Delay in reporting rape does not automatically destroy a complainant’s credibility, especially where the accused is a parent or authority figure whose threats, control, and proximity can explain the victim’s silence. But […]

When Credible Victim Testimony Convicts, But the Charge Still Controls the Penalty

Credible victim testimony sustained a rape conviction, but the death penalty was reduced because qualifying facts were not properly charged and proven. A rape conviction may stand on the credible, straightforward testimony of the victim, but the penalty cannot be increased to death unless the qualifying facts are properly alleged in the information and proven […]

When Child Testimony Convicts but Death Penalty Fails: The Rule on Proof in Incestuous Rape Cases

Child testimony sustained a rape conviction, but the death penalty was reduced because minority was not proved with the certainty required in qualified rape. A rape conviction may rest on the clear and credible testimony of a child victim, but the harshest penalty cannot be imposed unless every qualifying circumstance, including minority and relationship, is […]

When Rape Testimony Fails the Credibility Test, Presumption of Innocence Controls

Rape testimony may convict only when credible under the full record. Eliarda reversed a conviction because reasonable doubt remained on force and consent. An accusation of rape, standing alone, does not overcome the constitutional presumption of innocence when the testimony offered to prove force, intimidation, or lack of consent becomes materially weak, improbable, or inconsistent […]

Judges Cannot Use Administrative Referral Rules to Escape Criminal Cases

A judge cannot use administrative referral rules to avoid a criminal case. The Court fined a trial judge for gross ignorance of the law. Administrative referral rules for complaints against judges do not erase criminal jurisdiction. When a judge is charged in a criminal case, the trial court may proceed if the offense falls within […]

Delayed Reporting Does Not Defeat Credible Testimony, But Every Rape Count Must Stand Alone

A rape conviction may rest on credible victim testimony despite delayed reporting, but each count must still be proven as a distinct act beyond reasonable doubt. A complainant’s delay in reporting rape does not, by itself, destroy credibility when fear, threats, shame, family pressure, or emotional trauma explain the silence. But prosecutors must still prove […]

When a Child’s Testimony Alone Can Convict: The Viajedor Rape Ruling on Credibility, Alibi, and Penalty Proof

A rape conviction may rest on credible victim testimony, but death-qualifying facts like minority must be independently proven with competent evidence. A rape conviction may rest on the credible testimony of the victim alone, especially where the accused is a parent whose authority can overpower a child without the need for visible force or prolonged […]

When Testimony Alone Can Sustain a Rape Conviction in the Philippines

Credible victim testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite delayed reporting, failed alibi, and absence of spermatozoa in medical findings. A rape conviction may stand even without eyewitnesses, immediate reporting, or spermatozoa in the medical findings when the victim’s testimony is credible, consistent, and consistent with human experience. For accused persons, complainants, and families involved […]