Habeas Corpus Cannot Reopen a Final Conviction Over Disputed Land and Tax Records

Habeas corpus cannot reopen a final conviction over disputed land and tax records when the trial court had jurisdiction and appeal remedies were used. A person convicted after trial cannot use habeas corpus as a second appeal simply by recasting alleged errors in the appreciation of land titles, tax declarations, or documentary evidence as constitutional […]

When a Judge Misreads a Basic Probation Rule, Liberty Is at Stake

A judge was disciplined for mishandling probation and bond withdrawal after appeal, showing how basic criminal procedure rules protect liberty. Trial judges may be disciplined when they apply a basic criminal procedure rule in a way that unlawfully exposes an accused to arrest, detention, or loss of liberty. The ruling in Creer v. Judge Fabillar […]

Judges Cannot Privately Reopen a Decided Case After an Ex Parte Site Inspection

A judge was fined for privately inspecting the scene after judgment and using new information to acquit, violating impartiality and due process. A judge who has already decided a case cannot privately revisit the facts, conduct an ex parte ocular inspection, and use newly gathered information to change the result. The doctrine is simple but […]

When a Judge Refuses an Arrest Warrant, the Real Question Is Bad Faith โ€” Not Mere Disagreement

Judges may refuse arrest warrants absent probable cause without discipline, but may be reprimanded for leaving motions unresolved for months. Prosecutors, complainants, and accused persons cannot treat every unfavorable court order as judicial misconduct. A judge who refuses to issue an arrest warrant because probable cause has not been established is not administratively liable merely […]

Judges Must Avoid Private Contact With Litigants Even When No Bias Is Proven

Judges may be admonished for private contact with litigants even without proof of bias, because courts must preserve both impartiality and its appearance. Judges may be disciplined even when corruption is not proven if their conduct creates a reasonable appearance of partiality. For litigants, criminal complainants, accused persons, and lawyers, the lesson is practical: court […]

When a Judge Delays a Case, the Delay Itself Can Become Judicial Misconduct

A judge may be disciplined for unexplained delay and conduct creating an appearance of impropriety, even if bribery or actual bias is not proven. Litigants are entitled not only to a fair judge, but to a judge who acts with reasonable dispatch. A court may reject accusations of bribery or actual bias for lack of […]

Stealing Office Supplies Can End a Government Career: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Zero-Tolerance Rule for Court Employees

Supreme Court held that stealing office supplies by court personnel is grave dishonesty and misconduct, warranting dismissal, benefit forfeiture, and possible prosecution. Public employees who steal even ordinary office supplies can face the harshest administrative penalty: dismissal, forfeiture of benefits, disqualification from government employment, and possible criminal prosecution. For court personnel, the rule is even […]

Judges Cannot Blame Court Staff for Orders They Sign

A judge may be disciplined for negligence when signing a defective court order, even without proof of dishonesty and even after retirement. A judge who signs an order affecting money, liberty, or court procedure cannot later escape responsibility by saying that court staff prepared the papers. The Supreme Courtโ€™s rule in Padilla v. Judge Silerio […]