When Alcohol and Self-Defense Fail: The Supreme Court Clarifies Homicide Liability

The Supreme Court affirmed a homicide conviction, rejecting self-defense and clarifying that mere drinking does not prove mitigating intoxication. A person who admits stabbing another in claimed self-defense carries the burden of proving unlawful aggression, and mere drinking before the incident will not reduce criminal liability unless actual intoxication is clearly shown. The ruling is […]

Prolonged Tax Case Delay Leads to Dismissal Under Right to Speedy Trial

CTA En Banc denied a government motion in a criminal VAT case due to inordinate delay, affirming the accused’s right to speedy disposition despite no prescription. Taxpayers and corporate counsel should note that the timing of prosecutorial action in criminal tax cases is critical: unexplained delays in filing the Information or advancing the case can […]

Public Officials Can Be Convicted for Losing Government-Funded Goods Even Without Proof They Personally Pocketed Them

Public officials may face graft liability when government-funded goods received by their office are not distributed or accounted for, causing public loss. Public officers who cause the purchase of government-funded goods cannot escape liability by claiming they did not personally distribute the items or personally receive the money. When public property is procured for constituents, […]

Late Filing of Motion for Reconsideration Leads to Dismissal in Customs Case

The CTA denied a motion for reconsideration in a customs violation case for being filed beyond the 15-day period, underscoring strict compliance with procedural deadlines. Importers and businesses involved in customs compliance must be aware that strict deadlines for motions and submissions can determine the viability of a criminal case under the Customs Code. In […]

Tax Criminal Cases Can Survive Prescription but Still Fall to Prosecutorial Delay

A criminal tax case survived prescription because the DOJ complaint tolled the period, but was still dismissed due to over 10 years of unjustified delay. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still secure dismissal even when the government beats the five-year prescriptive period, if prosecutors allow the case to linger for years without adequate justification. […]

Old Fraud Claims Cannot Be Revived by Reframing Them as Trust Disputes

The Supreme Court held that old fraud claims cannot be revived as constructive trust disputes when evidence is weak and prescription has already run. A complainant who waits decades before filing a criminal case cannot restart prescription merely by later discovering missing records, demanding an accounting, or recasting the dispute as a constructive trust. For […]

Lawyers Who Mislead Jail Officials Can Face Discipline Even After Disbarment

The Supreme Court fined a disbarred lawyer PHP 300,000 for misleading jail officials and ruled him ineligible for judicial clemency. A lawyer who lies to jail personnel to secure a clientโ€™s release does not merely commit a private ethical lapse; the act strikes at the courtโ€™s control over criminal proceedings and may result in substantial […]

Tax Criminal Cases Can End Permanently When the Prosecution Fails to Prove Valid Assessment Service

A tax criminal case dismissal became final after demurrer was granted, with the prosecution barred from seeking reconsideration due to double jeopardy. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may obtain final relief when the prosecutionโ€™s own evidence fails to establish a legally sufficient basis for conviction, especially where the alleged tax assessment was not validly served […]

Judges May Defend Their Reputation, But Not Through Unapproved Press Conferences

A judge was cleared over alleged search warrant delay but fined for improper public conduct, media statements, and unapproved press activity. Judges are not administratively liable merely because they take time to examine a search warrant application, ask searching questions, or insist on proof of probable cause. But when a judge publicly intrudes into legislative […]

When Child Trafficking Becomes Qualified Trafficking: Why a Broker Cannot Escape Liability by Calling Himself a Mere Escort

Child trafficking broker liability affirmed: arranging, escorting, and collecting payment for a minorโ€™s exploitation can sustain qualified trafficking conviction. A person who arranges, accompanies, collects payment for, or otherwise brokers the sexual exploitation of a child may be convicted of qualified trafficking even if he claims he did not personally commit the sexual acts. For […]