Judges Are Not Liable for Delay When Due Process Requires Waiting

Delay by a judge is not misconduct when due process requires resolving ownership and hearing parties first; bad faith or malice must be shown. A judge’s delay in resolving a motion does not automatically amount to administrative misconduct when the delay is tied to a real need to hear all affected parties and settle a […]

Labor Disputes Cannot Be Repackaged as Civil Damage Cases

Civil courts cannot hear damages suits or issue injunctions when the dispute is rooted in unfair labor practice, union activity, or picketing. Employers cannot avoid the labor forum by filing a civil damages case when the dispute is rooted in alleged unfair labor practices, union activity, or picketing. When the acts complained of are intertwined […]

Expired CBAs Can Make Certification Challenges Moot: Why Timing Matters in Labor Disputes

A CBA certification challenge was dismissed as moot because the agreement had expired, leaving no practical relief for the Court to grant. Labor challenges can become legally useless when the agreement being attacked has already expired and no practical relief can still be granted. For employers, unions, and workers, Bongat teaches a hard procedural lesson: […]

When a Union Certification Fight Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Bargaining Rights for Vessels No Longer Operated

A union certification challenge was dismissed as moot after the employer stopped operating the vessels involved and the union showed no active interest. A union certification dispute can disappear before the court reaches the merits when the employer no longer operates the workplace or vessels involved, the union shows no continuing interest, and no present […]

Labor Officials Cannot Outsource Union Election Appeals to a Private Federation

Labor officials must decide certification election appeals themselves and cannot refer adjudication to a private federation, protecting workers from union election delay. Workers and employers in certification election disputes are entitled to a decision from the labor agency itself, not from a private labor federation. The ruling establishes a strict non-delegation rule in representation cases: […]

When a Criminal Case Can Proceed Without a Preliminary Investigation

City court criminal cases may proceed after preliminary examination when full preliminary investigation is not required under the applicable rules. Accused persons in city or municipal court cases cannot automatically stop a criminal prosecution by insisting on a full preliminary investigation; where the applicable rules allow a preliminary examination to determine probable cause, the case […]

When a Labor Case Settles During Appeal, the Court Can Still Turn the Compromise Into a Binding Judgment

A labor appeal may be dismissed after lawful compromise, with the Court approving the settlement and requiring compliance without deciding liability. Parties in a labor dispute may end an appeal by settlement, but once the Supreme Court approves their compromise agreement, that settlement becomes more than a private bargain. It becomes a binding judicially recognized […]

When Union Settlements Bind Workers: Labor Peace Can End Long-Running Pay Disputes

Union-approved labor settlements can bind dissenting workers when lawful, and attorney’s fee disputes cannot block compromises that restore industrial peace. Union members may be bound by a settlement approved by their legitimate union leadership, even when some members disagree, when the compromise ends a long-running labor dispute and is not illegal, immoral, or contrary to […]

A Case Cannot Be Dismissed Before the Facts Are Heard

Courts cannot dismiss civil cases on disputed facts without hearing evidence. Borje protects litigants from premature dismissal and denial of due process. Courts cannot short-circuit a lawsuit by dismissing it on disputed factual grounds before the parties are heard. When a complaint raises factual issues requiring proof, especially where both sides disagree on what happened, […]