Citizenship Challenges in Election Cases Cannot Be Used to Collaterally Attack a Parent’s Naturalization

The Court held that election quo warranto cannot collaterally attack a parent’s naturalization; citizenship challenges must follow the proper direct proceeding. A candidate’s citizenship may be questioned in an election contest, but that contest cannot be used as a backdoor attack on the naturalization judgment of the candidate’s parent. For elected officials, political opponents, and […]

RR No. 7-2011: Income Tax Rules on Excess Campaign Contributions and COMELEC Statement of Expenditures

RR No. 7-2011 taxes excess campaign contributions as income and bars expense deductions if the COMELEC Statement of Expenditures is not filed. Candidates, campaign treasurers, accountants, and political donors must treat unused campaign funds with care: campaign contributions are not automatically tax-free once the election is over. Under RR No. 7-2011, only campaign contributions actually […]

RMC No. 11-2010: COMELEC Election Ban Rules Affecting Government Hiring, Salary Increases, Transfers, and Local Official Suspensions

RMC No. 11-2010 circularized COMELEC Resolution No. 8737 on election-period restrictions affecting government hiring, salary increases, transfers, and suspensions. Government offices, officials, and employees dealing with civil service appointments, hiring, salary increases, transfers, details, and local elective official suspensions during the May 10, 2010 National and Local Elections had to observe the election-period restrictions under […]

RR No. 8-2009: Five Percent Creditable Withholding Tax on Campaign Expenditures and Campaign Contributions

RR No. 8-2009 imposes 5% creditable withholding tax on covered campaign expenditures and campaign contribution purchases by parties, candidates, and donors. Political parties, national and local candidates, and campaign contributors must withhold five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax on covered income payments for campaign-related goods and services. RR No. 8-2009 makes campaign spending a withholding […]

When Election Disputes Move From COMELEC to the House Electoral Tribunal

After party-list nominees take office, challenges belong in the HRET—not COMELEC or certiorari. The Court also upheld holdover authority and internal nominations. Once a party-list nominee has been proclaimed, has taken the oath, and has assumed office in Congress, challenges to that nominee’s right to sit no longer belong in COMELEC or in a direct […]

When a Judge’s Bad Ruling Becomes Administrative Liability

A judge’s careless, unsupported rulings may trigger administrative liability, but bribery or bias must still be proven by substantial evidence. A party who loses because of a judge’s patently unsupported ruling is not limited to an appeal. When the mistake shows a lack of diligence, violates judicial duties, or results in rash and unfounded decisions, […]

Overseas Voting Safeguards: SC Upholds Absentee Voting Law

Filipinos abroad may vote if domicile remains intact, but Congress cannot control COMELEC rules after passing election laws. The Overseas Absentee Voting Safeguards Doctrine confirms that Congress may allow qualified Filipinos abroad to vote without treating residence abroad as automatic abandonment of Philippine domicile. For overseas Filipinos, election lawyers, political candidates, and public-interest litigants, the […]

When Courts Delay, Public Interest Suffers: Why Election Cases Must Be Decided Fast

Judicial delay in election protests can amount to gross inefficiency, and a complainant’s desistance will not erase the Court’s disciplinary power over judges. Parties in election contests and other time-sensitive court cases are entitled to more than an eventual decision; they are entitled to a decision within the period fixed by law. In Rizon v. […]

When Judges Delay Election Cases: Why Settlement Talks Do Not Stop Court Deadlines

Judges cannot delay election protest rulings because parties are negotiating settlement; failure to decide within statutory periods may trigger discipline and fines. Judges cannot let urgent election cases sit unresolved simply because the parties are discussing settlement or because the court is busy. When the law fixes a short deadline for deciding an election protest, […]