Court Employees Can Be Fined for Office Harassment and Disrespectful Conduct During Work Hours

Court personnel may be fined for workplace shouting, humiliation, and disrespect during office hours when the conduct undermines public trust in the judiciary. Government employees, especially those connected with the courts, may be disciplined for abusive office behavior even when the misconduct consists mainly of shouting, humiliation, and disrespectful remarks made during work hours. The […]

When the Accuser Is Also Accountable: The Supreme Court’s Warning on Falsified Records and Abusive Discipline

The Supreme Court punished falsified attendance records but also dismissed a superior for abusive discipline, stressing evidence-based workplace accountability. Workplace misconduct does not give a supervisor a blank check to intimidate, humiliate, or bypass proper channels. In this consolidated administrative ruling, the Supreme Court applied a two-way accountability rule: court personnel who falsify attendance records […]

When a Strike Is Illegal, Workers Still May Not Be Automatically Fired

Illegal strike participation does not automatically justify dismissal; the Court ordered reinstatement and back wages where termination was excessive and anti-union. An illegal strike does not automatically give an employer a free hand to dismiss every worker who joined it. Even where a work stoppage is found unlawful, dismissal must still be measured against the […]

When a Union Election Cannot Be Delayed by Signature Challenges

The Supreme Court ordered a certification election despite signature disputes, emphasizing employee choice over delays in union representation cases. Workers seeking to choose a bargaining representative should not lose their chance at a certification election merely because the employer or a rival union questions the petitioning union’s signature count, especially where the workplace has had […]

When a Strike Skips the Grievance Process, Workers Can Lose Their Jobs

A union strike that bypassed a CBA grievance process was declared illegal, causing loss of employment status while preserving possible statutory benefits. Workers who walk out before using the grievance procedure promised in their collective bargaining agreement may turn a labor protest into an illegal strike, with the most serious consequence falling on union officers […]

Workplace Incivility in Court Offices Can Still Trigger Discipline Even When Charges Are Dismissed

Court employees may avoid liability when charges lack proof, but incivility and poor cooperation can still justify admonition in public service. Government employees, including court personnel, may escape formal liability when accusations of inefficiency, habitual tardiness, or falsified attendance entries are not proven by sufficient evidence, but they can still be admonished when the record […]

When Equal Pay Becomes a Legal Duty: What Employers Must Know About Wage Inequities and Collective Bargaining

PNR confirms that wage inequities may justify salary adjustments when comparable employees are treated unevenly and management fails to bargain in good faith. Employers cannot defeat wage-standardization claims simply by saying the company has limited funds, especially when the record shows that similarly situated employees in other departments received better treatment. Where employees performing comparable […]

Employers Must Stay Out of Union Certification Elections, Even During Workplace Unrest

Employers cannot block or influence certification elections; worker choice of bargaining agent remains protected even amid unrest or security concerns. Employers facing a union certification election cannot defeat or delay the process by claiming to protect employees from the union, by questioning the workers’ choice of bargaining agent, or by invoking general peace-and-order concerns. The […]

Workers Can Still Choose Their Union Even When Internal Union Politics Are Messy

The Court upheld a certification election despite union faction disputes, emphasizing worker choice and rejecting protests by an unregistered breakaway group. Employees do not lose their right to choose a bargaining representative simply because rival union leaders are fighting among themselves. When workers are given a peaceful and orderly certification election, and the winning union […]