Loss of Confidence Still Requires Proof: When Managers Can Fight Dismissal in the Philippines

Managers cannot be fired on suspicion alone. Loss of confidence requires proof and due process, while corporate officers are not personally liable absent bad faith. Employers cannot dismiss even high-trust managers on suspicion alone: loss of confidence must rest on substantial evidence, and the employee must receive notice and a real chance to answer before […]

Private School Principals Do Not Automatically Get Tenure in Administrative Posts

Private school teachers may keep faculty tenure, but do not automatically gain permanent tenure as principals or administrative officers after a fixed-term appointment. A private school teacher who has earned tenure as a faculty member does not automatically acquire a second tenure as principal, dean, coordinator, or administrative head. When a school validly appoints a […]

Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine: Illegal Strikes in Labor Disputes

Assumption of jurisdiction automatically orders strikers back to work; defiance makes the strike illegal and may justify loss of employment status. The Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine means that once the Secretary of Labor assumes jurisdiction over a labor dispute or certifies it for compulsory arbitration, striking workers must immediately return to work even if no separate […]

Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine: Limits on Work Injury Claims

Employers owe work injury medical costs only while disability subsists and treatment can still restore capacity, not as lifetime medical coverage. The Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine limits an employer’s liability for work-related medical expenses once the employee’s compensable disability has already reached the point where treatment can no longer restore him to work or to […]

Old Employee Money Claims Can Expire Fast: The One-Year Labor Code Transition Rule

Old employee money claims may be barred by prescription. The Court dismissed a delayed illegal dismissal and reimbursement claim under the Labor Code transition rule. Employees whose salary, separation pay, reimbursement, or illegal dismissal claims arose before the Labor Code took effect could not wait indefinitely to sue; for those pre-Code money claims, the Court […]

A Missed Service Copy Should Not Kill a Worker’s Labor Appeal

A worker’s NLRC appeal should not be dismissed for a non-prejudicial failure to serve a copy when substantial justice requires review on the merits. A labor appeal should not be dismissed on a purely technical defect when the worker timely filed the appeal, acted in good faith, and the missing copy to the employer did […]

When a Contractor’s Worker Is Not Your Employee: The Supreme Court’s Payroll-and-Control Rule for Job Contracting Disputes

A contractor’s worker was not Petrophil’s employee because Gersher hired and paid him; transfer and demotion were upheld absent unfair labor practice. A company that receives services from a contractor is not automatically the worker’s employer simply because the work is performed inside its premises. Where the records show that the contractor hired the worker, […]

Employers Cannot Fire an Employee for the Alleged Misconduct of a Spouse

An employee cannot be dismissed for a spouse’s alleged misconduct. The Court awarded separation pay and backwages instead of reinstatement. An employee may not be dismissed simply because her spouse is accused of immoral or wrongful conduct. For employers, schools, and religious institutions, the ruling establishes a practical boundary: workplace discipline must be anchored on […]

Overtime Pay Is Not Automatic: Employees Must Prove Authorized Work Beyond Office Hours

Employees must prove authorized overtime work, but employers may owe backwages when preventive suspension lacks a serious and imminent threat. Employees claiming overtime pay must do more than show that they stayed late, missed a time-out entry, or worked during a period when overtime was generally possible; they must prove that the overtime work was […]