When Illness Strikes at Work, Employers Must Prove It Is Not Work-Related

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise, shifting the burden in workplace compensation disputes. An employee who becomes ill while still employed does not always carry the full burden of proving exactly how work caused the illness. Under the compensability presumption applied in Tambasen, once the illness supervenes during employment, […]

Piece-Rate Workers May Still Be Employees: The Control Test in Philippine Labor Law

Piece-rate and pakyaw workers may still be employees when the business controls how work is done, affecting unfair labor practice and backwage claims. Workers paid by the piece, called only when work is available, or compensated under the familiar pakyaw arrangement may still be regular employees if the business retains the right to control how […]

When Absences Are Used as a Pretext: Union Activity Can Make a Dismissal Illegal

The Court held that absences cannot justify dismissal when the real motive is union activity, and a good-faith unfair labor practice strike is not illegal. Employers cannot rely on a workerโ€™s absences as a shield if the real reason for dismissal is union activity. The practical rule is simple but powerful: a company may have […]

Loss of Confidence Is Not a Shortcut to Fire Employees Without Proof

Employers cannot dismiss ordinary employees on vague loss-of-confidence grounds; Central Textile required proof, due process, and reinstatement when theft was unproven. An employer cannot convert an unproven accusation of theft into a lawful dismissal by calling it loss of confidence. For ordinary employees, security of tenure means that livelihood cannot be taken away on suspicion, […]

When an Illness Begins at Work, Employers Must Act Fast or Lose Key Defenses

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable, and an employer that fails to controvert the claim may waive key defenses. Workers whose illness begins during employment benefit from a powerful compensation rule: once the disease is shown to have supervened in the course of work, the law presumes it is work-connected, and an employer that […]

When a Worker Gets Sick on the Job, Silence Can Cost the Employer

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable, and an employer that fails to timely controvert the claim may lose its defenses. An employer that does not timely dispute a workplace illness claim may lose the right to contest compensation, and a worker whose illness appears during employment benefits from a legal presumption that the sickness […]

When Job Stress Makes Illness Compensable: The Presumption That Protects Long-Serving Employees

Illness that appears during employment may be presumed compensable, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection or aggravation. Employees who become ill while still in service do not always have to prove, with medical certainty, that their work alone caused the disease. Under the old Workmenโ€™s Compensation regime applied in Flores, once […]

When Union Settlements Bind Workers: Labor Peace Can End Long-Running Pay Disputes

Union-approved labor settlements can bind dissenting workers when lawful, and attorneyโ€™s fee disputes cannot block compromises that restore industrial peace. Union members may be bound by a settlement approved by their legitimate union leadership, even when some members disagree, when the compromise ends a long-running labor dispute and is not illegal, immoral, or contrary to […]

A Payroll Settlement Is Not a Waiver of Disability Compensation

A labor settlement for wage-related claims does not automatically waive a separate disability compensation claim when illness supervenes during employment. Employers cannot treat a labor settlement for unpaid wages, salary increases, bonuses, or living allowances as an automatic release of a separate disability compensation claim. When an employeeโ€™s illness supervenes during employment, the compensability presumption […]

When an Employee Falls Ill at Work, Technical Defaults Cannot Defeat Compensation Claims

Employee illness during work is presumed compensable when the employer fails to timely controvert, but benefits depend on the specific claim filed. Employees and their families may still recover workmenโ€™s compensation even when a claim has procedural defects, especially where the employer knew of the illness, failed to timely controvert the claim, and the record […]