When a Judgeโ€™s Wrong Decision Becomes Discipline: The No-Factual-Basis Rule

Judges are not disciplined for every wrong ruling, but a criminal conviction without factual and legal basis may justify sanctions for gross ignorance of the law. Judges are not punished simply because they are reversed on appeal, but a decision that convicts a person without explaining the factual and legal basis for each element of […]

Judges Who Use Media Platforms for Personal Attacks Can Be Removed from Office

Judges may be removed for public attacks and media conduct that erode impartiality, even outside the courtroom, when conduct shows judicial unfitness. Judges do not leave the obligations of judicial office at the courtroom door. When a judge uses a newspaper column, publication, or public platform to insult public officials, pursue personal quarrels, encourage litigation, […]

When a Judge Has a Family Tie to the Accused, Delay in Inhibition Can Become Judicial Misconduct

Judges related to a party must timely inhibit; good-faith settlement efforts cannot excuse delay when impartiality may reasonably be questioned. A judge who is related to an accused cannot keep handling a criminal case while trying to broker a private settlement between the parties. Even where the judge believes he is helping the parties resolve […]

When a Judge Misapplies Basic Criminal Procedure, Litigants Can Seek Administrative Discipline

A judge was suspended for misapplying criminal procedure, improper bail handling, and conduct creating an appearance of bias in local criminal cases. Litigants are not powerless when a judgeโ€™s procedural shortcuts affect criminal cases. A judge who skips basic steps required for warrants, misapplies the Rule on Summary Procedure, or creates the appearance of bias […]

Judges Can Be Sanctioned for Private Misconduct That Destroys Public Trust

Judges may be disciplined for private misconduct that destroys public trust, but only proven charges will support administrative liability. Judges do not leave judicial ethics at the courthouse door. A magistrate may be disciplined for private behavior that proves unfitness for the moral authority of the bench, even when the misconduct happens outside a courtroom […]

Hiding a Pending Case Can Cost a Judge His Office: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Disclosure Rule for Public Trust

The Supreme Court dismissed a judge for concealing a pending criminal case in his appointment papers, holding that acquittal does not cure dishonesty. Applicants to the judiciary and other public offices must disclose pending and past criminal or administrative matters honestly, even if the case is later dismissed or the applicant is eventually acquitted. The […]

Judges Cannot Delay Forcible Entry Cases Just Because Memoranda Were Not Filed

Judges may not delay forcible entry cases just because memoranda were not filed; ejectment remedies require prompt action and decision. Parties in forcible entry and detainer cases are entitled to prompt judicial action, and a judge cannot postpone decision-making merely because one side failed to file a memorandum. In summary ejectment proceedings, delay itself can […]

When a Judge Delays Your Case, Mandamus May Expose Administrative Liability

A judge may be reprimanded for delaying summary ejectment cases when inaction forces a party to seek mandamus and the excuse for delay is flimsy. Litigants are not helpless when a trial judge allows a supposedly summary case to stall: if a judge refuses or delays action despite a clear procedural duty, the delay may […]