PNB Employees Could Not Take Audit Disputes Straight to the Supreme Court

PNB employees could not appeal an Auditor General leave benefit disallowance directly to the Supreme Court; the proper remedy was appeal to the President. Employees of a government-owned or controlled corporation cannot automatically treat an adverse audit ruling as a private dispute appealable directly to the Supreme Court. When the employer is the Philippine National […]

Back Wages Require Proof of Actual Layoff, Not Equal Treatment Alone

Back wages require proof of actual layoff or lost work; employees cannot rely only on co-workers’ reinstatement when their facts are materially different. Employees who are excluded from a reinstatement award cannot obtain back wages merely by pointing to co-workers who received relief; they must show that their own separation, layoff, or exclusion from work […]

When Losing in Court Is Not Enough to Discipline a Judge

Adverse rulings do not prove judicial misconduct. PAFLU v. Tabigne requires clear evidence before a judge may be disciplined for alleged bias or delay. A party who believes a judge acted unfairly cannot secure judicial discipline merely by pointing to adverse orders, delay, or dissatisfaction with how a case was handled. The complainant must prove […]

When an Administrative Case Is Sent to an Investigator, Interim Motions Go There First

Administrative cases referred to an investigator route interim motions there first, clarifying how extensions and similar procedural requests are handled. Parties in administrative proceedings should not assume that every procedural request will be acted upon directly by the deciding court once the matter has already been referred for investigation. The practical rule from the PAFLU […]