Judges Cannot Let One Side Write the Decision: What Heck v. Judge Santos Means for Litigants

A judge may not let one party’s lawyer draft the court decision and adopt it verbatim; the proper remedy for legal error remains appeal, not discipline. A court decision must be the judge’s own work, not the handiwork of one party’s lawyer. For taxpayers, business owners, and litigants in civil or tax-related disputes, the practical […]

When a Lawyer Uses a Corporation to Take a Client’s Property, Disbarment Can Follow

A lawyer who used corporate control to exploit client property was disbarred, showing that corporate personality cannot shield fiduciary misconduct. Lawyers who control a client’s corporation cannot hide behind corporate formalities when they use that company to take over, mortgage, sell, or conceal the client’s property. In Cordon v. Balicanta, the Supreme Court treated the […]

Your Former Lawyer Cannot Weaponize Your Secrets Against You

A former lawyer was suspended for acting against a past client in related disputes, confirming that attorney-client confidentiality survives the end of engagement. A lawyer who once served as a client’s counsel, adviser, and confidant cannot later turn around and use knowledge gained from that relationship to assist the client’s opponents. The consequence is especially […]

Sheriffs Are Not Automatically Liable When a Levy Hits Property Claimed by a Third Party

The Court dismissed a complaint against a sheriff, holding that a disputed levy over third-party property should first be addressed through a Rule 39 third-party claim. A person whose property is seized to satisfy someone else’s judgment cannot automatically discipline the sheriff simply by saying the levy was wrong. The proper first remedy is usually […]

When Court Staff Delay Transcripts or Meddle in Notices, Litigants Can Seek Administrative Discipline

Court personnel may be disciplined for meddling in court notices and delaying transcripts, protecting litigants from procedural irregularities and record delays. Litigants are not helpless when court personnel interfere with court notices, appear to favor one side, or delay the preparation of transcripts needed for a case. The doctrine from this ruling is straightforward: court […]

Judges Cannot Grant Bail on Recognizance Before the Accused Is in Custody

Courts cannot grant bail or recognizance before custody attaches; judges who ignore this basic rule may be disciplined for gross ignorance of the law. A person who has not yet been arrested or voluntarily surrendered cannot be released on bail or recognizance, because there is no custody from which the court can release him. For […]

When Your Lawyer Switches Sides: Why Conflicted Counsel Can Be Suspended

A lawyer was suspended for representing conflicting interests without written consent, reinforcing client loyalty and conflict checks in litigation. A lawyer who represents clients with opposing interests, even in related civil disputes arising from the same controversy, risks suspension from the practice of law because loyalty is not optional in legal representation. For taxpayers, corporations, […]

When a Lawyer Misses a Deadline, the Client Can Seek Discipline and Reimbursement

Clients may seek discipline and reimbursement when a lawyer misses appellate deadlines, fails to file required pleadings, and causes procedural harm. Clients are not helpless when their lawyer loses a case through missed appellate deadlines. A lawyer who obtains an extension but still fails to file the required pleading may be disciplined, suspended from law […]

When a Judge May Refuse to Issue an Arrest Warrant Despite a Prosecutor’s Finding of Probable Cause

A prosecutor’s probable cause finding does not automatically require arrest; judges must independently decide whether a warrant is justified. A prosecutor’s finding of probable cause does not automatically send an accused person to jail. Before an arrest warrant may issue, the judge must make a separate judicial determination that probable cause exists for arrest and […]