When a Lawyer Uses Cases as Revenge: The Rule Against Vindictive Litigation

A lawyer may be suspended for filing multiple complaints as retaliation, because vindictive litigation reflects unfitness to practice law. Lawyers may be disciplined not only for courtroom misconduct, but also for using the legal system itself as a weapon of harassment. The doctrine from the Saburnido ruling is simple but powerful: a lawyer who files […]

When a Lawyer Loses Track of a Case, the Client Does Not Lose the Right to Accountability

Clients may hold lawyers accountable for neglecting a case, failing to give updates, and losing track of litigation, including return of fees. A lawyer who accepts a case must carry it to its conclusion, keep the client informed, and cannot escape discipline by saying that he forgot, became busy, or relied on the client to […]

Court Employees Can Be Suspended for Abusive Conduct Inside the Courthouse

Court personnel may be suspended for abusive or violent courthouse conduct that undermines public trust, even when the incident begins as an office dispute. People who deal with the courts are entitled to more than correct orders and timely hearings; they are entitled to be treated with dignity by every court employee, from the judge […]

Judges Who Miss the 90-Day Decision Deadline Can Still Be Fined After Retirement

Judges who fail to decide submitted cases within the 90-day period may be fined for gross inefficiency, even after retirement. Courts do not treat delayed decisions as a mere internal scheduling problem: a judge who fails to decide submitted cases within the constitutional period may be held administratively liable and fined, even when the audit […]

When a Lawyer Turns Settlement Talks Into a Litigation Weapon, Ethics Rules Can Step In

A lawyer was reprimanded for soliciting a reconsideration letter for settlement, then using it in court against the writer without fair candor. A lawyer who invites an opposing party to write a reconsideration letter as a possible path to settlement may commit professional misconduct if he later uses that same letter against the writer in […]

When Fee Collection by a Lawyer Becomes an Ethics Caseβ€”and When It Does Not

A disputed lawyer’s fee claim is not automatically malpractice. Disbarment requires clear, convincing proof of deceit, gross misconduct, or unethical conduct. A client who disagrees with a lawyer’s later fee claim does not automatically have a disbarment case. The controlling lesson is evidentiary: professional discipline requires clear, convincing, and satisfactory proof of deceit, malpractice, or […]

Sheriff Execution Expenses Must Pass Through the Court, Not the Sheriff

Sheriffs cannot privately collect execution expenses from litigants. The Court fined a sheriff for bypassing court approval, deposit, and liquidation rules. Litigants enforcing a judgment should not be asked to hand over execution money directly to a sheriff. When a writ requires expenses for transportation, guarding, storage, or similar costs, the sheriff must first secure […]

Filing the Same Property Dispute in Multiple Courts Can Get Your Case Dismissed With Prejudice

Forum shopping in related property cases can lead to dismissal with prejudice, contempt, fines, and lawyer sanctions when parties file overlapping suits in different courts. Litigants cannot improve their chances by filing the same property dispute in different courts and waiting to see which forum appears more favorable. When the same parties, issues, and reliefs […]