A Desistance Affidavit Cannot End a Public Crime Without Prosecutorial Scrutiny

Affidavit of desistance cannot alone dismiss a public crime; the judge was fined for mishandling preliminary investigation records. Victims and heirs cannot privately erase a criminal case simply by signing an affidavit of desistance, especially when the offense charged is a public crime. In Padua v. Judge Molina, the Supreme Court made clear that judges […]

Judges Cannot Delay Urgent Property Cases by Ignoring Clear Procedural Rules

A judge was fined for allowing a prohibited extension and delaying a forcible entry case, reaffirming that clear summary procedure rules must be followed. When a procedural rule is clear, a judge cannot delay a case by treating the rule as optional. This ruling matters to litigants in urgent property disputes because the Court made […]

When a Judge Sits on an Urgent Injunction Request, Delay Itself Can Become Misconduct

A judge may deny or defer an injunction, but prolonged inaction on urgent interim relief can be misconduct warranting sanction and corrective action. Urgent court relief is not supposed to disappear into the docket. When a party asks for a preliminary injunction, the judge must act on the request within a reasonable time by granting […]

When the Complaint Does Not Allege a Non-Bailable Firearms Offense, Bail Cannot Be Denied by Assumption

A judge was cleared for granting bail where the firearms complaint did not allege the qualifying circumstance needed to make the charge non-bailable. An accused cannot be treated as facing a non-bailable firearms offense simply because a firearm was allegedly connected to a killing. The charging document must expressly allege the qualifying circumstance that makes […]

When a Court Officer Has a Stake in the Case, Public Trust Becomes the Issue

Court personnel may be suspended for acting in a case where they have a personal connection, even without proof of bribery or threats. Court personnel who involve themselves in private disputes connected to their official duties may be disciplined even when the record does not prove bribery, intimidation, or a direct quid pro quo. The […]

When Court Criticism Becomes Contempt: The Line Between Legitimate Advocacy and Scurrilous Attacks

The Court fined a complainant for indirect contempt after unfounded attacks on justices, clarifying when strong criticism of court delay becomes punishable. Litigants may criticize judges and court decisions, but they cross into contempt when their language stops being a good-faith challenge to legal error and becomes a scurrilous attack on the integrity of the […]

Judges Are Protected for Good-Faith Errors, But Not for Basic Legal Ignorance

A judge is protected for good-faith judicial errors, but may be fined for gross ignorance when a basic rule on reckless imprudence is violated. Judges are not disciplined merely because they make wrong rulings, but they may be sanctioned when the mistake reveals ignorance of a basic legal rule that every trial judge is expected […]