When a Lawyer Asks for Fixer Money, Discipline Can Follow Even Without Proof of a Completed Bribe

A lawyer was suspended for falsely claiming immigration officials demanded money, confirming that clients may seek discipline for fabricated government-fee demands. Clients who are told that government papers will move faster if money is paid to unnamed officials have a disciplinary remedy against the lawyer making that representation. The ruling in In re Atty. Arturo […]

Judicial Delay Complaints Need Proof of Bad Faith, Not Frustration With the Court

A judge is not administratively liable for delay, exhibit management, or encouraging family compromise absent proof of bad faith, coercion, or misconduct. A judge is not administratively liable for delay, strict courtroom management, or efforts to settle a family dispute unless the complainant proves misconduct, bad faith, coercion, or abuse of authority. For litigants, the […]

Court Delay Complaints Need Proof, Not Suspicion Alone

Court delay may justify an administrative complaint, but misconduct must be proven and prosecuted. Suspicion and nonappearance can lead to dismissal. A litigant who believes a judge delayed a case or favored the other side may file an administrative complaint, but delay alone will not prove misconduct. The practical lesson from the Espinas ruling is […]

When a Bar Applicant’s Oath Cannot End a Misconduct Complaint

A pre-oath complaint may proceed as lawyer discipline after admission where due process is observed and no substantial prejudice results. A person accused of serious misconduct before becoming a lawyer cannot avoid disciplinary scrutiny simply because he has already taken the lawyer’s oath. In Limalima v. Sanjurjo, the Court treated the pre-oath proceeding as sufficient […]

When Clients Settle Behind Their Lawyer’s Back, Attorney’s Fees May Still Survive

A client may settle a case without counsel, but a recorded contingent fee can survive if the compromise unfairly defeats the lawyer’s lien. A client may compromise or dismiss a case without the lawyer’s consent, but that freedom does not automatically erase the lawyer’s right to be paid when the settlement unfairly defeats a valid […]

Lawyers Who Acquire Client-Related Property Are Not Automatically Disbarred Without Proof of Conflict

A lawyer was not disbarred where his land interest predated representation and no actual conflict, false pleading, or client prejudice was proven. A lawyer’s purchase or acquisition of property connected to litigation does not, by itself, justify disbarment when the interest was acquired before the lawyer entered the case, the client knew of the interest, […]

When a Lawyer Takes Filing Fees But Never Files the Case

A lawyer who receives filing fees but never files the case breaches professional ethics if he misleads the client about the filing status. A client who gives a lawyer money for court filing fees is entitled to the truth: if the case was not filed, the lawyer cannot pretend that it was. Liwag v. Neri […]

When Disbarment Is Lifted: The Supreme Court’s Second-Chance Rule for Lawyers After Discipline

The Supreme Court lifted a lawyer’s disbarment after nearly two years, holding that reinstatement may follow when discipline has served its purpose. A lawyer who has been disbarred is not automatically beyond professional redemption. In a narrow but important ruling, the Supreme Court recognized that reinstatement may be granted when enough time has passed, the […]