Church Property Sales Can Be Undone When Internal Approval Rules Are Ignored

Unauthorized church property sales may be unenforceable, and titled land may still be reconveyed through constructive trust if action is filed on time. Religious corporations and other entities with internal approval rules cannot rely on a single officer’s signature to dispose of real property when their governing documents require collective consent. A buyer who receives […]

When a Lost Case Cannot Be Revived: The Rule 47 Lesson for Businesses Facing Foreclosure

The Court held that a lawyer’s neglect is not extrinsic fraud under Rule 47 and cannot automatically revive a final foreclosure-related dismissal. A business that loses a case because its own lawyer failed to monitor the proceedings cannot automatically revive the case by calling that neglect β€œextrinsic fraud.” For annulment of judgment to prosper, the […]

Military Reservation Land Rule: Void Titles Revert to the State

Military reservation land is inalienable; titles issued without proof of private rights may be cancelled and reverted to the State. The military reservation land rule is a warning to private claimants and property buyers: even a final Torrens title may be cancelled if the land was inalienable public land and the registration court had no […]

A Signed Deed Is Not Enough: When a Land Sale Can Be Annulled for Lack of Consent

A signed deed and title may be annulled when no true consent to sell exists, the corporation lacked board authority, and notarization was defective. A property owner may recover land even after a signed deed of sale and a transfer certificate of title exist if the evidence shows that he never consented to sell, the […]

Free Patent Fraud Proof Rule: When Reversion Fails in Land Cases

Free patent titles may survive reversion unless the State proves actual fraud with clear evidence in Philippine land title disputes. The Free Patent Fraud Proof Rule protects titled landowners from losing property merely because the government later questions a land patent. In Philippine property disputes, a registered free patent may still be attacked by the […]

Just Compensation Objection Waiver: Why Delay Can Defeat Expropriation Appeals

In expropriation cases, parties waive attacks on commissioners and valuation reports by failing to object within Rule 67 deadlines. Property owners and expropriating agencies cannot sleep on procedural objections in just compensation cases. The Just Compensation Objection Waiver doctrine means that a party who fails to timely object to the appointment of commissioners or to […]

Same Evidence Rule: When Ejectment Cases Become Forum Shopping

Separate ejectment suits fail when the same evidence proves one land claim; tax declarations alone do not defeat actual possession. Property claimants cannot multiply ejectment suits by slicing one land dispute into separate cases when the same evidence is needed to prove the same claimed right of possession. The Same Evidence Rule in unlawful detainer […]

Co-Owner Ejectment Rule: When One Heir Can Recover Property

One co-owner may file ejectment for co-owned property if the action benefits all co-owners and occupants remain only by tolerance. The Co-Owner Ejectment Rule allows one heir or co-owner to file an ejectment case to recover possession of co-owned property, even without joining every other co-owner as a plaintiff, so long as the case is […]