Filing a Redemption Case Is Not Enough to Keep a Foreclosed Property

A borrower cannot stop possession after foreclosure by filing judicial redemption alone; payment or consignation of the redemption price is required. A borrower who wants to recover foreclosed real property cannot preserve possession merely by filing a case for judicial redemption. The redemption action must be timely, brought in good faith, and supported by payment […]

Homeowners’ Association Disputes Belong Before the Housing Regulator, Not the Regular Courts

Homeowners’ association disputes over construction rules and penalties belong before the housing regulator when they involve member by-laws, not the RTC. Homeowners who challenge subdivision association penalties, construction rules, or board enforcement actions cannot avoid the housing regulator simply by styling their lawsuit as one for declaration of nullity or damages. When the real dispute […]

Alienable Land Rule: When Long Possession Still Fails

Possession before land is alienable and disposable cannot ripen into ownership, defeating title registration despite decades of occupation. The Alienable Land Rule makes one point painfully clear for landowners: decades of farming, fencing, tax declarations, and family transfers do not by themselves create registrable ownership if the land was not yet classified as alienable and […]

A Corporation’s Appeal Should Not Die Over a Curable Secretary’s Certificate Defect

Corporate appeals may survive late proof of signatory authority, while tenants who keep keys after moving out may still unlawfully withhold possession. A corporate litigant that timely files a verification and certification against forum shopping should not automatically lose its appeal merely because proof of the signatory’s board authority was submitted later, so long as […]

When Government Takes Private Land, the Initial Deposit Must Follow the Current Tax Declaration

Local governments must use the current tax declaration and 15% deposit rule for expropriation possession, while final judgments cannot be endlessly relitigated. In expropriation cases, a local government cannot rely on the old Presidential Decree formula that fixed provisional compensation at 10% of the assessed value. When a municipality seeks immediate possession of private property, […]

Tax Declarations Can Support a Property Claim, But They Cannot Replace the Real Owners in Court

Tax declarations and real property tax payments may support ownership claims, but partition cases fail when indispensable heirs or co-owners are not impleaded. Real property tax declarations and years of tax payments may help prove a claim of ownership, possession, or beneficial use, but they cannot make a defective land case valid when the people […]

Fraudulent Free Patent Rule: When Torrens Title Can Be Cancelled

Fraudulently obtained free patent titles may be cancelled despite Torrens indefeasibility when the applicant lacked occupation and cultivation rights. The fraudulent free patent rule warns landowners that a Torrens title issued from a free patent is not untouchable when the applicant was never legally qualified to obtain it. In Philippine property disputes, registration protects valid […]

Permit Denied? Exhaust Zoning Appeals Before Asking a Court to Compel Approval

Courts cannot compel discretionary zoning approval by mandamus when an administrative appeal remains available for a denied permit or locational clearance. Businesses denied a zoning or locational clearance cannot usually bypass the administrative appeal process and ask a court to force approval by mandamus. When a specialized agency or appellate body can still review the […]

Unsigned Property Sale Drafts Do Not Create Tax and Transfer Obligations Without Consent

Draft deeds and tax clauses do not bind parties without consent and corporate authority. The Supreme Court rejected specific performance in a failed property sale. Property owners and corporate buyers are not bound by tax, transfer, and payment terms merely because draft deeds circulated between them. A sale of real property is perfected only when […]

A Registered Title Is Not Enough: Why Bad Faith Can Defeat a Later Buyer of Land

A later buyer who registers land despite notice of a prior sale is not protected. Good faith remains essential in double sales of registered property. A person who buys land with notice of another buyer’s prior claim cannot rely on a clean-looking certificate of title to defeat that earlier right. In a double sale of […]