A Missed Pre-Trial Brief Should Not Automatically Cost You the Case

A late pre-trial brief did not justify default where the parties appeared in court; certiorari was allowed because appeal was inadequate. Litigants who appear in court should not lose their entire case merely because a pre-trial brief was filed late, especially when the Rules penalize failure to appear at pre-trialβ€”not failure to submit a brief […]

Probation Cannot Be Denied Merely Because Jail Seems Better

Probation cannot be denied based only on a judge’s belief that imprisonment is better when the accused is eligible and the record supports rehabilitation. A person who is legally eligible for probation cannot be refused that remedy simply because a trial judge believes imprisonment would be more morally satisfying, socially symbolic, or personally corrective. In […]

A Defective Motion Can Cost You the Case: When Missing Hearing Notices Make Judgments Final

A defective motion for reconsideration without notice of hearing does not stop the appeal period, allowing the judgment to become final and executory. A party who files a motion for reconsideration without the required notice of hearing may lose the right to appeal entirely, because such a defective motion is treated as a mere scrap […]

Support Pendente Lite Can Be Made Retroactive When Non-Support Created Debt

Support pendente lite may be made retroactive when non-support caused debt and the paying spouse has means to pay, especially in conjugal property disputes. A spouse who receives no support while a case is pending may ask the court to make interim support retroactive, especially where the lack of support forced that spouse into debt […]

A Lost Ejectment Case Cannot Be Revived Through Certiorari

Losing occupants cannot use certiorari to revive missed appeals in ejectment cases; final judgments may be executed despite ownership claims. Tenants, occupants, and property claimants who lose an ejectment case cannot later stop demolition by filing a separate certiorari action if they simply failed to use the ordinary remedies available to them. The ruling draws […]

When Government Delay Makes a Case Moot: Why Mandamus Requires a Live Controversy

Mandamus against a government agency may be dismissed when later events remove the live controversy, even if the original refusal raised constitutional issues. A person asking the courts to compel a government agency to act must still have a live, practical dispute by the time the case is decided; if the facts that gave rise […]

Certiorari Is Not a Shortcut When an Ordinary Appeal Is Available

Certiorari cannot replace an available appeal. Enriquez v. Rivera warns litigants that using the wrong remedy may doom even a serious procedural challenge. Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy, not a second route for a losing litigant who still has an ordinary appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, employers, and businesses challenging adverse court or agency orders, […]

When a Tenant Withdraws an Appeal, Execution Does Not Rewind Time

A withdrawn appeal makes a judgment final only upon effective withdrawal and remand; a lessee may receive indemnity for improvements but cannot force a land sale. A party who appeals a judgment and later withdraws that appeal cannot treat the case as if the appeal never existed. The judgment becomes final only when the withdrawal […]

Wrongful Attachment and Replevin Bonds: When a Surety Can Still Be Made to Pay Damages

A timely bond-damage claim preserves recovery for wrongful replevin or attachment, but the surety must receive notice and a summary hearing before liability. A party whose property is wrongfully seized under a provisional remedy is not limited to winning the main case. If the writ of attachment, injunction, replevin, or receivership caused damage, the injured […]