Deficiency VAT Criminal Case Fails When the Final Assessment Notice Has No Definite Due Date

A deficiency VAT criminal case remained dismissed because the assessment lacked a definite due date and actual receipt of the FAN/FLD was not proven. Taxpayers facing criminal prosecution for alleged willful failure to pay deficiency VAT may challenge the case at its foundation if the government cannot prove actual receipt of a valid Final Assessment […]

Tax Criminal Cases Can Be Lost on E-Copy Compliance, Not Only on the Merits

A criminal tax Information was treated as not submitted after prosecutors missed the required electronic-copy compliance period before the Court of Tax Appeals. Tax prosecutors and revenue officers cannot treat electronic-copy compliance as a clerical afterthought: when a criminal tax Information is personally submitted in paper form but the required electronic counterpart is not transmitted […]

Late Certiorari Filings Can Sink Challenges to BIR Garnishment Orders

Taxpayers challenging BIR garnishment must file on time, attach certified copies, and comply with CTA e-filing rules or risk dismissal. Taxpayers challenging BIR collection actions must move quickly, attach the proper certified documents, and comply with electronic filing requirements, because even serious objections to an assessment may be dismissed outright when a petition for certiorari […]

Late Tax Appeals Can Defeat Even Substantive BIR Assessment Challenges

A taxpayerโ€™s late appeal from a BIR assessment decision was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, confirming the strict 30-day Court of Tax Appeals deadline. Taxpayers who receive an adverse assessment decision from the Commissioner must file their appeal with the Court of Tax Appeals within the 30-day statutory period, because even potentially serious objections to […]

Willful Failure to Pay Tax Cases Require Proof of Both Notice and Tax Liability

Criminal tax prosecution for willful failure to pay tax failed after the court found insufficient proof of all elements and civil tax liability. Taxpayers facing criminal prosecution for alleged willful failure to pay tax cannot be convicted on assumptions about receipt of BIR notices, possession of documents, or unpaid liabilities; the prosecution must still prove […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Fail When the Government Files Too Late or Contradicts Its Own Records

Criminal tax charge dismissed after the Court found prescription and rejected the prosecutionโ€™s later claim on the FAN receipt date. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still secure dismissal when the governmentโ€™s own assessment records show that the alleged offense has already prescribed, especially where the prosecution later attempts to revise a key date that […]

U-Freight Phils Settles Tax Liability via Judicial Compromise Agreement

U-Freight Phils resolved assessed IT, VAT, EWT, and DST liabilities via judicial compromise, paying PHP16.2M and ending CTA Case No.10886. Taxpayers engaged in domestic freight and logistics operations now have a reinforced example of how judicial compromise can resolve disputed tax liabilities. U-Freight Phils., Inc. successfully settled its assessed deficiencies in income tax, value-added tax, […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Make Tax Refund and Tax Credit Victories Final

A late government appeal made a CTA refund or tax credit victory final, with service on the OSG controlling the appeal deadline. Taxpayers who win a refund or tax credit case before a CTA Division may be able to rely on that victory becoming final when the Commissioner fails to perfect an appeal on time, […]

Excise Tax Refunds Fail Without Originals: What Fuel Importers Must Prove in Tax Credit Claims

Fuel excise tax refund denied after photocopied payment records and late electronic evidence theory failed to prove actual payment of taxes. Fuel importers and suppliers seeking excise tax refunds or tax credits must be prepared to prove actual tax payment with admissible evidence, not merely scanned or photocopied records, especially when the government timely objects […]