When the BIR Keeps an Overpayment, It Cannot Charge Interest on the Same Money

A taxpayer overpayment already held by the government must reduce later deficiency interest; the BIR cannot charge interest on funds it should credit or refund. Taxpayers who overpay taxes by mistake are not automatically delinquent on the full amount of a later deficiency if the government was already holding money that rightfully belonged to them. […]

Imported Finished Goods Can Turn Royalty Deductions Into Tax Assessments

Royalty payments to foreign affiliates may be disallowed as deductions when computed on imported finished goods outside the governing regulatory approval. Philippine companies cannot automatically deduct royalty payments to foreign affiliates merely because the payments are described as business expenses. When a royalty or technical service fee is computed on finished goods imported from the […]

When Taxpayers Refuse to Show Their Books, the BIR May Reconstruct the Tax Due

When taxpayers withhold or fail to produce books, the BIR may reconstruct liability using the best evidence obtainable, and assessments are presumed correct. Taxpayers who refuse or fail to produce their books of accounts cannot expect a court to strike down a BIR assessment merely because the BIR relied on indirect evidence. Where tax records […]

When Occasional Port Calls Still Trigger Philippine Income Tax for Foreign Shipping Companies

Foreign corporations with only occasional Philippine port calls may still owe tax on Philippine-source freight income, computed on gross receipts. A foreign company does not escape Philippine income tax merely because it has no branch, office, or license to do business in the country. If it earns income from Philippine sources, even through isolated port […]

Foreign Dividend Tax Refunds Require Proof of Actual Tax-Sparing Benefit

Philippine dividend tax refunds based on tax-sparing credits require proof that the foreign parent actually qualified for the foreign tax credit. Philippine subsidiaries claiming a refund or tax credit on dividends paid to a foreign parent must prove more than the existence of a treaty-like or statutory tax-sparing clause. They must show that the foreign […]

When the BIR Disallows Business Deductions, Evidence and Fair Procedure Still Matter

Businesses can deduct proven, reasonable expenses, and a timely substantive protest may preserve remedies against a BIR tax assessment. Taxpayers may deduct legitimate business expenses when they can prove that the payment was actually made, reasonable in amount, and necessary to the businessβ€”even if the Bureau of Internal Revenue suspects that the transaction looks unusual, […]

Foreign Airlines Can Be Taxed on Philippine Ticket Sales Even Without Landing Here

Foreign airlines may owe Philippine tax on local ticket sales despite no Philippine flights, but good-faith legal error does not automatically prove tax fraud. Foreign airlines that sell tickets in the Philippines may owe Philippine income tax on those sales even if their planes never land in the country. The controlling doctrine is source-based taxation: […]

Tax Refunds Can Be Offset Against Deficiency Taxes Even While the Assessment Is Being Challenged

Tax refunds may be credited against outstanding deficiency taxes, and questioning a BIR assessment does not automatically stop collection. A taxpayer entitled to a refund may still receive nothing in cash if the government can lawfully apply that refund against an outstanding tax deficiency. In Cebu Portland Cement, the Supreme Court confirmed a practical rule […]

When Tax Assessments Are Based on Guesswork, Taxpayers Can Fight Back

A tax assessment based on estimates and presumptions cannot stand without factual proof. Taxpayers may challenge speculative BIR computations before the CTA. Taxpayers may defeat a tax assessment when the government relies on presumptions, estimates, or mathematical projections instead of actual facts. In Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Island Garment Manufacturing Corporation, the Court reaffirmed […]