Excess Input VAT Carryovers May Not Defeat a Deficiency VAT Assessment When Disallowed Credits Were Carried Forward

Excess input VAT carryovers did not defeat a deficiency VAT assessment where disallowed credits were carried forward; compromise penalties were cancelled. VAT-registered taxpayers with both taxable and exempt transactions must be prepared to prove not only that they have large excess input VAT balances, but also that disallowed input VAT credits were not carried forward […]

Excess CWT Refund Upheld Despite BIR Objections on Timing, Exhaustion, and Documentation

A tax refund claim for excess CWT was upheld despite BIR objections on timing, exhaustion, and documentation after the motion for reconsideration was denied. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit for excess creditable withholding taxes should not lose a valid claim merely because the judicial case was filed shortly after the administrative claim, provided […]

Wrong Appeal Mode Can Still Threaten Criminal Tax Cases Despite a Timely Notice of Appeal

Criminal tax appeals from RTC original jurisdiction require a timely notice of appeal, not a petition for review; the wrong remedy was denied. Parties in criminal tax cases must choose the correct appeal route immediately after an RTC ruling, because a petition for review is not the proper remedy when the RTC acted in its […]

Missed BIR Protest Deadlines Can Make Deficiency Tax Assessments Immediately Collectible

A taxpayer lost its challenge to a P30.25M BIR assessment after failing to protest the FLD/FAN on time; the distraint and levy warrant was upheld. Taxpayers who receive a Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices must file a proper administrative protest within the statutory period, because a later challenge to a collection warrant […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the BIR Ignores a Taxpayer’s Protest Evidence

The CTA cancelled major BIR assessments after finding due process violations and ruled that related-party service and distribution fees were not royalties. Taxpayers facing large BIR assessments should not treat the protest stage as a mere formality: when the BIR fails to address substantial explanations and documents submitted against a Preliminary Assessment Notice, the resulting […]

Late BIR Appeals Can End Tax Assessment Cases Before the Merits Are Reached

The CTA dismissed the Commissioner’s late appeal, holding that service on the OSG controlled the deadline and deprived the Court of jurisdiction. Taxpayers who win before a Division of the Court of Tax Appeals may secure finality when the government misses the strict appeal deadline, even where the Bureau of Internal Revenue received the court […]

Tax Evasion Charges Can Fail Before Trial When the Information Is Defective

A criminal tax case was dismissed after prosecutors failed to correct defects in the Information, highlighting key defenses in tax evasion prosecutions. Prosecutors pursuing criminal tax cases must ensure that the Information is complete, accurate, and supported by required attachments, because unresolved pleading defects may result in dismissal before the accused is ever required to […]

Taxpayers Can Defeat BIR Assessments When PAN Replies Are Ignored

Taxpayer defeats P440.35M BIR assessment after the tax court found the PAN reply was timely and the BIR failed to consider its defenses. Taxpayers facing large BIR deficiency assessments should treat the Preliminary Assessment Notice stage as a critical due process battleground: when a timely PAN reply is ignored, or when the BIR issues assessment […]

Foreign Branches Can Defeat BPRT Assessments When the BIR Cannot Prove Profit Remittance

Foreign branches are not liable for BPRT without proof of actual or constructive remittance; the assessment and compromise penalties were cancelled. Foreign corporations operating Philippine branches or regional operating headquarters should not be assessed branch profit remittance tax merely because they earned income; the BIR must prove that profits were actually remitted, applied, or earmarked […]

Real Property Tax Refunds for Power Projects: When LGUs Must Return Excess RPT After Condonation

Tax court upheld a β‚±209.5M RPT refund for an independent power producer and rejected a new refund-claim requirement after final judgment. Independent power producers operating under build-operate-transfer arrangements may recover excess real property taxes already paid under protest when a final judgment applies a lawful reduction or condonation scheme, and local governments cannot require a […]