VAT Refunds for Export Sales Survive BIR Appeal When the Taxpayer Proves Administrative Compliance

Exporters claiming VAT refunds can defeat broad BIR objections when records show administrative compliance and the claim involves zero-rated export sales of goods. Exporters claiming VAT refunds or tax credit certificates should not be defeated by broad objections from the Commissioner unless the BIR can identify the specific documentary defect that justified the disallowance. In […]

Tax Criminal Cases Can Be Dismissed for Prosecutorial Delay Even When the Case Has Not Prescribed

Criminal tax charges may be dismissed for inordinate prosecutorial delay even when prescription has not set in, protecting taxpayers’ speedy disposition rights. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may invoke the constitutional right to speedy disposition of cases when the government waits years before filing the information, even if the State’s right to prosecute has not […]

Good-Faith Tax Protest Defeats Criminal Tax Evasion Charge, But Deficiency Tax Still Must Be Paid

A taxpayer was acquitted of willful failure to pay tax due to reasonable doubt, but the corporation remained liable for deficiency income tax. Taxpayers accused of willfully refusing to pay a BIR assessment may avoid criminal conviction when the evidence shows a good-faith dispute, but acquittal does not automatically erase the underlying tax liability. Businesses […]

Corporate Rehabilitation Does Not Automatically Wipe Out Local Tax Liabilities After Plan Approval

Rehabilitating companies get only a time-bound FRIA local tax waiver. Taxes after plan approval remain due despite a continuing stay order. Businesses under court-supervised rehabilitation cannot assume that a standing stay order permanently removes local business tax, real property tax, penalties, interests, and charges after a rehabilitation plan has already been approved. For distressed corporations […]

Aromatic Hydrocarbon Used for Tire Manufacturing May Escape Excise Tax When Use Is Proven

Importers may recover excise tax and VAT on excise tax when aromatic hydrocarbon is proven used for tire manufacturing, but refunds depend on documented volume. Importers of petroleum-derived products should not assume that a laboratory classification alone will settle excise tax liability. Where the product is sold and actually used as raw material for tire […]

BIR Collection Warrant Voided After Defective Service of Tax Assessment Notices

Taxpayer defeated a Php 11.5M BIR assessment after defective service of notices voided the assessment and collection warrant. Taxpayers who never validly received a formal demand and final assessment notice may still challenge a BIR collection warrant, even where the Bureau insists that the assessment has already become final and executory. The ruling is a […]

VAT Refund Claims Cannot Be Denied Solely for Lack of Prior Zero-Rating Approval

A VAT refund claim may not be denied solely for lack of prior BIR zero-rating approval where the taxpayer proves the legal and factual basis for zero-rated sales. VAT-registered suppliers claiming refunds or tax credit certificates for input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales should not lose their claim merely because they did not secure a […]

Five-Day Delay Defeats Government Appeal in Tax Code Criminal Case

A five-day delay defeated the government’s tax criminal appeal, reinforcing that CTA appeal periods are mandatory and jurisdictional. Tax criminal cases can be lost before the merits are even reached when an appeal is filed late. For taxpayers and business owners facing prosecution for alleged Tax Code violations, this resolution underscores a critical procedural protection: […]

Pasay Property Owners Win Refund After Transfer Tax Was Computed on Full Property Value

Taxpayers won a P2.61M refund after Pasay transfer taxes were computed on full property values instead of the inherited and donated shares actually transferred. Real property owners who pay local transfer taxes on inherited, donated, or renounced property shares should verify whether the city computed the tax on the actual share transferred, not automatically on […]

E-Filing Defects Can Stop Tax Criminal Cases Before Arraignment

A criminal tax Information for alleged failure to remit withholding taxes was deemed not filed after prosecutors failed to submit the required electronic copy. Tax prosecutors, corporate officers, and companies facing criminal tax charges must treat electronic filing before the Court of Tax Appeals as a jurisdiction-critical compliance step, because even an Information physically filed […]