Late Tax Protest Leads to Dismissal of Petition Against CIR Assessment

Taxpayer’s delayed petition challenging a CIR deficiency tax assessment and compromise denial dismissed due to lack of jurisdiction and late filing beyond statutory 30-day period. Taxpayers must carefully observe the statutory deadlines for filing a judicial protest against a final decision on disputed assessments. Missing the 30-day period for appeal from the Commissioner’s final decision […]

Wrong Zonal Value Can Support a Capital Gains Tax Refund, Tax Court Says

Tax court granted a capital gains tax refund after finding the BIR used the wrong zonal value and improperly imposed surcharge and excess interest. Real property sellers who paid capital gains tax based on an overstated zonal value may recover the excess tax, surcharge, and interest if they can prove the correct valuation through competent […]

BPO Exporters Can Still Recover Input VAT, But Only With Strict Invoice Compliance

BPO exporters may recover input VAT on zero-rated sales, but strict invoice defects can drastically reduce the refundable tax credit amount. Philippine BPO and outsourced service providers selling services to foreign clients may recover unutilized input VAT from zero-rated sales, but the refund will be reduced sharply when supporting invoices, official receipts, or purchase documents […]

No 10-Year Tax Assessment Period Without Proof of Fraudulent Return

A tax accused remained free from civil liability because the CTA found no proven fraudulent return and the deficiency income tax assessments for 2009 and 2010 had prescribed. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still defeat a related civil claim for unpaid taxes when the government cannot prove that the return was fraudulent or false […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the FLD Ignores the Taxpayer’s PAN Reply

A 2015 BIR assessment was cancelled after the FLD repeated the PAN without addressing the taxpayer’s reply, violating due process under Section 228. Taxpayers facing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should carefully preserve and document every reply, protest, and supporting document submitted during audit because an assessment may be cancelled when the BIR issues a […]

Excise Tax Refunds on Airline Commissary Imports Survive Reconsideration Challenge

Airline taxpayer preserved a P27.28M excise tax refund, but failed to expand it without stronger proof of local non-availability for all imported items. Airlines and other taxpayers claiming tax refunds must prove entitlement with competent, transaction-specific evidence, but a favorable refund award will not be disturbed on reconsideration unless the losing party raises new, compelling […]

Late Government Appeals Can End Tax Crime Cases Before the Merits Are Heard

A criminal tax appeal was dismissed after the government missed the deadline, making DOJ receipt controlling over later BIR receipt in tax prosecutions. A tax prosecution can collapse before the appellate court ever reaches the alleged tax violation when the government misses the deadline to seek further review. For taxpayers, corporate officers, and defense counsel […]

Davao Environmental Charges May Fall Outside CTA Review When They Are Regulatory Fees

Environmental charges may fall outside CTA jurisdiction when primarily regulatory, not revenue-raising. The taxpayer’s refund petition was dismissed. Businesses challenging local government exactions must first determine whether the charge is truly a local tax or merely a regulatory fee, because that classification can decide whether the Court of Tax Appeals may review the dispute at […]

Importers Can Defeat Customs Forfeiture When Fraud Is Not Clearly Proven

Importers may recover declared goods when customs fraud is not proven by clear and convincing evidence, despite undeclared items or permit issues. Importers facing seizure or forfeiture of shipments should not lose declared goods merely because customs authorities suspect fraud from undeclared or permit-deficient items. Where fraudulent intent is not proven by clear and convincing […]

Tax Assessments Can Still Fall When BIR Audit Authority Is Defective

Tax court denied the Commissioner’s reconsideration bid, preserving the taxpayer’s win where BIR audit authority and LOA defects defeated the assessment. Taxpayers facing deficiency assessments should examine not only the computation of the alleged tax liability, but also the authority of the revenue officers who conducted the audit. In this assessment dispute, the tax court […]