PEZA Companies May Still Recover Input VAT Paid Before Zero-Rating Rules Were Clarified

PEZA enterprises may recover input VAT paid before zero-rating rules were clarified if VAT was actually shifted and properly proven. PEZA-registered enterprises that paid input VAT before the BIR clearly adopted the zero-rating treatment for sales from the Customs Territory to ecozone enterprises may still recover that VAT when the tax was actually shifted to […]

Tax Refunds Follow the Statute, Not Later Tax Increases

Tax refunds must follow the exact statute granting them; later tax increases do not enlarge refund claims absent clear legislative authority. Taxpayers claiming a statutory refund cannot enlarge that refund by using later tax rates unless the law clearly says so. In CDCP Mining, the Supreme Court applied a practical but strict rule for tax […]

When the BIR Changes Its Mind, Taxpayers Should Not Pay for the Past

The Court barred retroactive application of a changed BIR VAT ruling where Benguet relied on prior zero-rating rules and would suffer prejudice. Taxpayers may invoke the non-retroactivity rule when the BIR reverses its own prior interpretation after the taxpayer has already structured, priced, and completed transactions in reliance on that interpretation. The doctrine is especially […]

Banks Cannot Exclude Final Withholding Tax From Gross Receipts Tax

Banks cannot deduct final withholding tax from interest income when computing gross receipts tax; withheld tax remains part of taxable gross receipts. Banks claiming refunds of gross receipts tax cannot reduce their taxable receipts by the final withholding tax already taken from interest income. For banking institutions, tax withheld at source on passive interest income […]

BIR Tax Compromise Invalidated: Why Public Revenue Cannot Be Bargained Away

A tax compromise with the BIR was voided for violating law and public policy, leaving PNB liable for withholding tax and preserving the informer’s reward. Tax compromise agreements are not immune from judicial review. When a settlement with the Bureau of Internal Revenue sacrifices public revenue, ignores statutory limits, or rewards a taxpayer who failed […]

When a BIR Tax Assessment Is Based on Weak Evidence, Taxpayers Can Fight Back

The Supreme Court held that the BIR may reconstruct income using available evidence, but assessments based on unreliable photocopies may be challenged. Taxpayers may challenge a deficiency tax assessment when the assessment is built on unverified photocopies or unsupported estimates, but they cannot defeat the BIR merely by refusing to produce their own records. In […]

PEZA Companies Can Recover Input VAT When Ecozone Purchases Are Treated as Zero-Rated Exports

PEZA export enterprises may recover input VAT on capital goods when ecozone purchases are effectively zero-rated and refund requirements are proven. PEZA-registered export enterprises are not automatically barred from recovering input VAT simply because they enjoy tax incentives. When their purchases are treated as effectively zero-rated under the ecozone framework, VAT paid on capital goods […]

RMC No. 1-2005: December 2004 Tax Credit Certificates and Tax Refund Disbursement Vouchers Circularized for Court-Ordered Refunds

RMC No. 1-2005 circularized December 2004 Tax Credit Certificates and Disbursement Vouchers for court-ordered tax refunds in favor of taxpayers. Taxpayers with court-ordered tax refund claims from December 2004 should verify whether their Tax Credit Certificates or Disbursement Vouchers were included in RMC No. 1-2005, because the issuance circularized the BIR’s list of tax refund […]

A Defective Tax Waiver Cannot Extend the BIR’s Assessment Deadline

A defective BIR waiver cannot extend the tax assessment period. The Supreme Court voided a late assessment and distraint based on an invalid waiver. Taxpayers may defeat a tax assessment when the Bureau of Internal Revenue relies on a waiver that does not clearly, validly, and mutually extend the assessment period. A waiver of the […]

When Tax Litigants Accuse a Judge: Suspicion Is Not Evidence of Corruption

Judicial misconduct complaints require clear and convincing proof; adverse rulings in tax or business disputes must be challenged through proper remedies. Parties in tax and commercial litigation cannot convert an adverse ruling, delayed order, or suspected backroom influence into judicial discipline without clear, direct, and convincing proof. The doctrine is practical and unforgiving: accusations of […]