When a Criminal Charge Must Allege the Facts That Raise the Penalty

A rape conviction was affirmed after the charge alleged minority and sibling relationship, showing how pleaded facts can set the penalty ceiling. A criminal charge does more than accuse; it sets the ceiling of punishment. In rape prosecutions, qualifying circumstances such as the victim’s minority and the offender’s relationship to the victim can justify the […]

When a Criminal Information Fails to Allege Relationship, the Death Penalty Cannot Stand

Rape conviction affirmed, but death penalty reduced because the information failed to allege the precise qualifying relationship required by law. A person charged with rape cannot be sentenced to the gravest qualifying penalty unless the facts that make the crime qualified are expressly alleged in the criminal information. Even where the evidence proves a close […]

A Guilty Plea Does Not Automatically Justify the Death Penalty When the Information Fails to Allege Qualifying Circumstances

The Court affirmed rape convictions but reduced the death penalty because minority and relationship were not alleged in the informations. An accused may admit guilt, and the evidence may strongly show a grave offense, but a court cannot impose the highest possible penalty unless the facts that legally justify that penalty were clearly alleged in […]

A Criminal Information Limits What the Court May Convict You Of

A rape charge alleging force did not support conviction for simple seduction because deceit was not alleged. Courts may convict only on the charge as written. A person charged with one crime cannot be convicted of another offense unless the lesser offense is necessarily included in the charge as written. In Barba, the Court applied […]