When Court Delay Becomes Judicial Neglect: What Litigants Can Do When a Case Stalls

A judge may be fined for years of delay in deciding a submitted case, even if a decision is later issued, absent proof of a valid extension. A judgeโ€™s heavy docket, pandemic duties, administrative assignments, and personal circumstances do not automatically excuse years of inaction. For litigants whose cases have been submitted for decision but […]

Judicial Errors Are Not Misconduct: When a Losing Party Cannot Turn a Court Ruling Into an Administrative Case

The Supreme Court held that alleged judicial errors cannot support discipline without proof of bad faith, dishonesty, corruption, or gross ignorance. A party who believes a judge made a wrong ruling must generally use the proper judicial remedy, not an administrative complaint, unless the alleged error is shown to be tainted by fraud, dishonesty, corruption, […]

Judges May Defend Their Reputation, But Not Through Unapproved Press Conferences

A judge was cleared over alleged search warrant delay but fined for improper public conduct, media statements, and unapproved press activity. Judges are not administratively liable merely because they take time to examine a search warrant application, ask searching questions, or insist on proof of probable cause. But when a judge publicly intrudes into legislative […]

Sexual Harassment Complaints Against Judges Still Require Proof, Not Suspicion Alone

The Supreme Court dismissed a sexual harassment complaint against a judge, holding that serious allegations still require substantial evidence and moral certainty. Administrative complaints for sexual harassment in the Judiciary may begin with an anonymous report, but they cannot end in discipline unless the accusation is proven by substantial evidence and creates moral certainty from […]

When a Judge Holds Arraignment Outside Open Court, the Case Becomes a Public Trust Problem

A judge was fined for chamber arraignment, delayed proceedings, and apparent bias, reaffirming that criminal arraignment must be done in open court. Criminal defendants, complainants, and litigants may insist that arraignment be done in open court, not informally or privately, because the arraignment is the moment when the criminal case formally joins issue and allows […]

When a Judgeโ€™s Ruling Feels Wrong, the Remedy Is Appeal โ€” Not an Ethics Complaint

The Court held that adverse judicial rulings must be challenged by appeal or certiorari, not ethics complaints, absent proof of bias or misconduct. A party who loses an urgent court ruling cannot turn an appealable judicial act into an administrative case against the judge or justice who issued it. The doctrine is practical and important: […]

When a Judge Delays a Case, Retirement Will Not Erase Accountability

A judge who failed to decide a submitted case for years was fined despite retirement, confirming that judicial delay violates speedy disposition rights. A judge who lets a case sit unresolved beyond the constitutional deadline may still be disciplined even after retirement, and the penalty may be taken directly from retirement benefits. For litigants, the […]