When the BOI Cannot Take Back a Tax Holiday Without Substantial Evidence

The Supreme Court held that BOI tax incentives cannot be withdrawn without a written legal basis and substantial evidence of noncompliance. Investment incentives cannot be withdrawn merely because an agency later disagrees with how a registered enterprise implemented its project. When the government grants an income tax holiday subject to conditions, the agency seeking to […]

Water District Managers Can Keep Good-Faith Pay, But Future Salaries Must Follow the Salary Standardization Law

Water district managers remain covered by salary standardization, but good-faith recipients may avoid refunding COA-disallowed pay. Local water districts may fix the pay of their general managers, but that discretion stops at the Salary Standardization Law. The practical consequence is twofold: compensation above the lawful salary grade may be disallowed by the Commission on Audit, […]

Government Employees May File Discipline Complaints Directly with the Civil Service Commission

Government employees may file administrative complaints directly with the CSC, which shares original jurisdiction with agency disciplinary bodies. Public officials and employees cannot defeat an administrative case merely by arguing that the complaint was filed by the wrong kind of complainant. When an administrative complaint against a government employee is brought directly before the Civil […]

When the Civil Service Commission Can Discipline State University Employees Directly

The CSC may directly discipline state university employees and impose preventive suspension when their position could compromise an investigation. Government employees in state universities cannot defeat an administrative case merely by insisting that only their schoolโ€™s governing board may discipline them. When a complaint alleging civil service violations is brought directly before the Civil Service […]

Electric Cooperative Directors Can Be Removed by NEA Even After EPIRA Loan Assumption

NEA retained authority to discipline electric cooperative directors after EPIRA, but punitive agency action still requires proper notice and due process. Electric cooperative directors cannot defeat NEA disciplinary authority simply by arguing that EPIRA transferred or assumed the cooperativeโ€™s loan obligations. For board members, officers, consumers, and electric cooperative stakeholders, the practical rule is clear: […]

Public Employees May Organize, But They Cannot Strike: What Teachers and Government Workers Must Know

Public employees may organize and seek redress, but cannot strike or disrupt services. The ruling clarifies suspension, due process, and back wages. Government employees may join associations and seek redress for workplace grievances, but that constitutional protection does not give them the right to strike, walk out, or paralyze public services. For public school teachers […]