When a Government Board Cannot Perpetuate Itself: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Rule on Appointments in Public Corporations

The Supreme Court held that a government corporation board cannot fill its own trustee vacancies when doing so violates presidential appointment power. Government corporations cannot use their charters to create self-perpetuating boards when the Constitution reserves appointment power to the President or to constitutionally recognized appointing authorities. For public officers, trustees, and regulated entities dealing […]

COA Audit Jurisdiction Doctrine: Limits on Charging LWDs Fees

The SC ruled LWDs are government-owned and subject to COA audits; attempts to classify them as private to evade fees are invalid. Government entities must now recognize that local water districts (LWDs) are not private corporations and remain subject to audit by the Commission on Audit (COA). This ruling clarifies that attempts to exempt LWDs […]

When Workplace Hostility Becomes an Administrative Offense in Government Offices

Government workplace hostility can be punished as discourtesy even when incompetence or gross misconduct is not proven, resulting in reprimand. Government employees may avoid liability for serious accusations such as incompetence or gross misconduct, yet still face administrative discipline when their workplace behavior undermines public service, disrupts office cooperation, and harms institutional trust. For businesses, […]

Public Utility Over-Recovery: When Customers Must Be Refunded

Public utilities cannot pass income tax as operating expense or keep excess collections beyond the authorized return; customers may be refunded. The public utility over-recovery doctrine protects consumers from being charged rates that let a regulated utility earn more than the lawful return allowed by regulators. For businesses and households, the practical rule is direct: […]

Void Laws Do Not Create Valid Replacements: Why Unconstitutional Office Removals Can Require Reinstatement and Back Pay

Unlawfully removed public officers may obtain reinstatement and back pay when their removal and replacements stem from an unconstitutional law. Government officials removed from office under an unconstitutional statute may recover their positions, salary, and tenure rights when their supposed replacements derive authority from the same void law. The practical lesson is simple: when government […]

Government Reorganization Pay Is Not a Second Retirement Benefit

A retired judge could not count already compensated judicial service again to increase MMDA separation pay after reorganization, absent clear statutory authority. Government employees who already received retirement gratuity for prior public service cannot automatically reuse those same years to enlarge a later separation package after a government reorganization. Santos draws a practical line between […]

Court Employees Can Lose Their Jobs When Private Immorality Undermines Judicial Integrity

Court employees may be dismissed for private immoral conduct when an illicit relationship undermines judicial integrity and public confidence in the courts. Court employees may be dismissed from government service when their private conduct shows a continuing immoral relationship that damages the dignity of the courts, even if the misconduct happens outside the courtroom and […]

Full Ownership Transfer Rule: When Land Grants Shift Control

Full land ownership transfers control and income rights; existing concessions survive only to protect operations, not old agency authority. The Full Ownership Transfer Rule means that when Congress transfers public land in full ownership to a new owner, existing concessions may survive, but the power to collect income from the land and supervise its use […]

Oil Price Regulation Rule: When Courts Defer to ERB Decisions

Administrative agencies may grant provisional rate increases when due process is observed and substantial evidence supports the regulatory order. The oil price regulation rule means that courts will not easily overturn provisional fuel price increases when the agency has acted within its authority, observed administrative due process, and relied on substantial evidence. For businesses and […]

Provisional Oil Price Hikes: When ERB May Act Without Prior Hearing

Agencies may grant provisional rate relief without prior hearing when law allows it, subject to later hearing and final review. Provisional rate relief may be granted before a full hearing when the regulating agency is acting under a statute that expressly allows temporary relief based on verified papers, subject to a later hearing and final […]