When Circumstantial Evidence Is Enough to Convict: Lessons from the Lozada Robbery with Homicide Ruling

Circumstantial evidence can sustain a robbery with homicide conviction when proven facts form an unbroken chain pointing to guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction may stand even without an eyewitness to the actual killing when independent circumstances form one unbroken chain pointing to the accused as the perpetrators. For persons facing criminal charges, complainants […]

A Guilty Plea in a Capital Case Is Not Enough Without a Searching Judicial Inquiry

The Supreme Court set aside a death sentence because the trial court accepted a guilty plea without a searching inquiry and evidence on the charge. A person accused of the gravest crimes cannot be condemned on a bare plea of guilty unless the trial judge first makes sure, on the record, that the accused fully […]

A Guilty Plea Can Still Lead to the Harshest Penalty When the Court Makes a Searching Inquiry

A guilty plea in a capital case may admit aggravating facts if the court conducts a searching inquiry and evidence supports the conviction. An accused who pleads guilty to a capital offense does not automatically escape trial safeguards, but once the court confirms that the plea is voluntary, informed, and supported by evidence, that plea […]

When a Deadly Weapon Is Alleged but Not Proven, Death Cannot Be Imposed

A rape conviction was affirmed, but the death penalty was reduced because the alleged deadly weapon was not clearly proven to justify the harsher punishment. A criminal conviction may stand while the penalty is reduced when the prosecution proves the crime but fails to clearly prove the circumstance that makes the punishment harsher. In rape […]

A Guilty Plea Does Not Automatically Prove Aggravating Circumstances in Robbery With Homicide

A guilty plea in robbery with homicide does not automatically prove aggravating circumstances; unsupported premeditation and nocturnity cannot justify a harsher penalty. A person who pleads guilty to robbery with homicide does not automatically admit every aggravating circumstance alleged against him when those circumstances are unsupported by the evidence. For accused persons, victims, and families […]