Compromise Judgments Can Be Voided When an Indispensable Property Owner Was Left Out

A compromise judgment may be void if an indispensable property owner was omitted from the case, but courts must still examine knowledge, laches, and estoppel. A person whose claimed ownership rights are directly attacked in a property case cannot be cut out of the lawsuit and then bound by a compromise judgment. When an indispensable […]

When a Lost Case Cannot Be Revived: The Rule 47 Lesson for Businesses Facing Foreclosure

The Court held that a lawyerโ€™s neglect is not extrinsic fraud under Rule 47 and cannot automatically revive a final foreclosure-related dismissal. A business that loses a case because its own lawyer failed to monitor the proceedings cannot automatically revive the case by calling that neglect โ€œextrinsic fraud.โ€ For annulment of judgment to prosper, the […]

Final Judgment Bar: Why Old Property Claims Cannot Be Refiled

Final judgments bar repeat property claims; annulment requires extrinsic fraud and must be filed in the proper court, not as a second trial. The Final Judgment Bar prevents losing parties in a Philippine property dispute from relitigating ownership after a court has already issued a final judgment on the same land, between the same parties, […]